Sunday, January 25, 2009

How Far does your Duty Reach?

Your liability for negligence reaches as far as your causation does. In most cases, that means if your negligence created the situation in which damages occurred--directly through your own action or inaction--then whatever you set into motion can come back and bite you in the a$$.

So if you let a horse get loose and it travels 200 miles and 4 months later someone gets hurt, are you still in trouble? Yep.

Next we will talk about liability for animals that get away from you and your property. These loose animals are called estrays.

Estrays can cost you. The people they hurt have signed no sort of release at all.

Not Negligence.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TeVwzNIfCzc

You may think it's stupid, unwise or asking for trouble, but it ain't negligence. Nobody has a duty to themselves. No duty, no breach, no negligence.

If the horse freaked out and harmed the rider? maybe then, but the woman under the horse has no one to sue. It's her horse, her idea and her choice.

What Negligence Looks Like: Part IV and final. For now.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gtWbMDZtjuw

Knew or should have known. Should this person have known there was a high risk of a horse bucking when wearing a saddle for the first time? Was the time and place safe and appropriate?

Thursday, January 22, 2009

What Negligence Looks Like: Part III

You are a facility owner. 3 days a week you rent to H/J shows. All mounted people must wear helmets on those days. 3 days a week you rent out to Western sports. Helmets are not required.
Your facility is made out of metal and you like to park tractors in the ring during speed events. But its OK because everyone knows only jumping is dangerous.

I chose one without small children getting smashed into metal fences.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oGjAcQtg54&feature=related

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

What Negligence Looks Like: Part II

Part of being an instructor is knowing when your students are ready to do more challenging tasks. That's part art and part experience. We know if we wait too long to allow our students to jump, they may get bored and go somewhere else. If we let them jump too soon, they may get hurt and you get sued.

Here, IMHO, is too soon. I am not picking on the kids. They are very cute. I am not picking on the useful and saintly horses. They are also cute. I am simply showing an example of "too soon" and if you go to court with a hurt student and this video bring your checkbook. The camera person is out from lessons with a broken arm.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AjsU2Atp_SU

Too soon? Just fine?

Tuesday, January 20, 2009

What Does Negligence Look Like?

Negligence is almost by definition a hindsight view. If nothing goes wrong there was probably no negligence, or there was no reason to look for it because there was no damage done. If something goes wrong your every action becomes scrutinized. What you did, when you did it and what you did not do all matter.

Remember, torts 101--duty, breach, causation and damages.

Lets build on that a little and add some more small rules. You have no duty to assist or rescue anyone. However, once you begin or initiate a rescue, you now have a duty to make sure that person is OK until handed off to safety. Safety would be home, a hospital, the police etc. . .

So, lets say you are the instructor of a lesson. Student crashes at fence. Do you have a duty? Yes. You are in charge and giving the directions. But you are not liable unless there is negligence and damages. Student gets up, shakes off dirt, you say nothing, student re-mounts and tries again. More duty? No. But if you attempt a rescue, for example if you step forward to ask if student is OK, then you have a duty to make sure student is actually OK. You have assumed another duty and begun a rescue attempt.

The common law reason behind this rule is that someone else will be discouraged from helping because they believe you have things covered. So if you act like its your duty it becomes your duty.

Student crashes in your lesson and you ask if he is OK and then let him continue and the next day student have massive brain malfunction? Your problem? Yep. You assumed a duty and if you did not see student through to the ER for that CAT scan you might be liable. Remember, all those fancy laws and waivers won't protect you from negligence.

Now you have "what you knew or should have known" plus "what you did or should have done".

Here is an example. Rescue attempt or not? Comments are open.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pu4gyoIvD5I&NR=1

Wednesday, January 14, 2009

Read the Titles on the Right >>>>>>>>>>

I posted a really long Dog law entry so look at the titles of older posts if there is something you are looking for. The last post will scroll on forever:> The titles on the right are like a table of contents to the blog entries. And, as always, topics are read from bottom up. Last post on a topic shows up first.