Tuesday, January 13, 2009

Once Again its Readers Choice. . .

We have done death, do you want to do taxes now? If you already paid your taxes, do you want to learn about bankruptcy for animal owners? Last choice is doing some hypos with liability? I will do all three eventually, but if any of these subjects are timely to you 4 followers, give a shout out!

First to e-mail wins!

The FL case Continues. . . Thanks HSUS.

Topic: Flagler Humane Society cuts staff, hours, services


PALM COAST — Too many animals and too little money are putting the squeeze on the Flagler Humane Society.

Effective immediately, the shelter is reducing its days of operation, suspending its low-cost spay and neuter certificate program, and laying off two part-time employees, director Donna Howard said Monday in a press release.

"We, being a private non-profit organization, were just a victim of the economy like hundreds of other businesses," Howard said by phone Monday, stressing "we will do whatever we have to do to keep our doors open."

According to Howard, the number of animals being surrendered to the humane society has skyrocketed recently as more residents lose their jobs and their homes.

"The animals are the first to go," she said. "You can’t get rid of your children."

While donations are down, Howard said the community did provide critical support during recent events surrounding the Pig Tails Sanctuary.

"The pig sanctuary expenses were taken care of by donations specifically for them, so I thank all of those people from the bottom of my heart. Without them we might have been in this situation sooner," Howard said.

County spokesman Carl Laundrie said today the county wasn’t aware of the shelter’s actions.
http://www.news-journalonline.com/newsjournalonline/breakingnews/humane011209.htm

Saturday, January 10, 2009

The Bill with Comments: Mine and Yours!

A BILL to amend the Code of Virginia by adding in Title 3.1 a chapter numbered 4.9 consisting of sections numbered 3.1-22.78 through 3.1-22.82, relating to the sale of horses by dealers.
Dealer is not defined. We can be pretty sure its not an occasional sale or a private sale of your personal horse. It might be defined elsewhere in the code, but the intended parties are those who make a substantial portion from their income from horse sales, pay personal income taxes as a professional or have some kind of business. I think it s valid point to ask for this to be defined.


Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia:

1. That the Code of Virginia is amended by adding in Title 3.1 a chapter numbered 4.9, consisting of sections numbered 3.1-22.78 through 3.1-22.82, as follows:

Chapter 4.9.

Equine Sales by Dealers.

§ 3.1-22.78. Definitions.
As used in this chapter, unless the context requires a different meaning:
"Dual agent" means a person acting as representative for both the buyer and the seller in any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine. Auction companies shall not be considered dual agents.
"Equine" means a horse of any breed used for racing or showing, including prospective racehorses, breeding prospects, stallions, stallion seasons, broodmares, yearlings, or weanlings, or any interest therein.

§ 3.1-22.79. Written bill of sale required.
If you are selling a horse for more then $10K, you can afford some ink and paper. You should have bills of sale anyway. Horses do not have titles like cars and houses do, this is a step in the right direction. In addition, its hard to cheat and make up numbers if all parties can see the sales price. If you want to add a few thousands bucks on without telling the owner, buy the horse and the resell it. Otherwise, you are already breaking the laws of agency regardless if this law gets passed.

A. Any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine over $10,000 shall be: (i) accompanied by a written bill of sale or acknowledgment of purchase and security agreement that includes the purchase price; and (ii) signed by both the purchaser and the seller or their agent or, in a transaction solely relating to a season or fractional interest in the stallion, the syndicate manager or stallion manager.

B. If the equine is sold, purchased, or transferred at public auction, the requirements of this section may also be satisfied by the issuance of an auction receipt generated by the auction house, and signed by the purchaser or his agent. An agent who signs an auction receipt on behalf of the principal shall do so only if authorized in writing. When presented with such authorization, all other parties to the transaction may presume that an agent signing on behalf of the principal is authorized to act for the principal. For transactions at public auction, this section shall not require disclosure of the reserves, the identity of the principals, or the auctioneer's commissions.

§ 3.1-22.80. Dual agency; consent required; agency; consignor; disclosure of compensation.
This should already be done. There should be no need for a new law to make this enforceable, but clearly, from the fact that opposition exists, this bill needs to pass. I have to have consent for dual representation, real estate people have to do it, all other professionals and agents have to do it, why shouldn’t horse dealers have to do it? Are they hiding something? If following the law is going to cut into your income, then be happy nobody has enforced it until now, but you are not special or magic or above the law.

A. Any person acting as a dual agent in any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine shall acquire the prior written consent of both the buyer and the seller.

B. Any person acting as a dual agent, consignor, or agent for either a purchaser or a seller in a transaction involving the sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine who may receive compensation, in any form, with a value in excess of $500 shall disclose the payment in writing to both the purchaser and seller; and acquire the written consent for such compensation from each principal for whom the agent is acting.

C. Any person acting as a dual agent, consignor, or agent for either a purchaser or a seller in a transaction involving the sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine shall, upon request by the principal, furnish copies of all financial records and financial documents in the possession or control of the agent pertaining to the transaction with the principal. Financial records shall not include the agent's or owner's work product used to internally evaluate the equine.

§ 3.1-22.81. Civil action for violation of chapter.

Again, not a new concept. Fraud almost always carries this with it. You pay for the lawyers and you pay punitive. The point is to teach you to not rip people off, even if you grew up thinking it was OK. You have not been sued up until now because the cost of litigation often exceeds the amount stolen. This evens up the playing field and no part of this bill was designed or Promoted by lawyers as a way to get more $$$$$. Most lawyers are not even aware of the prices top horses command or the amount of potential litigation out there. If they were, this bill would not be needed. This bill is for clients to take to their lawyers and lawyers to take to the judges so everybody clearly understands fraud in a horse deal is just as much “real” money as any other kind of fraud. We do not buy and sell horses with Monopoly money. Who is behind this bill? Horse owners who have been ripped off.

A. Any person who violates this chapter shall be civilly liable for damages in treble the amount of the damages sustained by the complaining party. The prevailing party in any litigation under this section shall be entitled to an award of costs of the suit, reasonable litigation expenses, and attorney's fees. As used in this section, treble damages shall equal three times the sum of: (i) the difference, if any, between the price paid for the equine and the actual value of the equine at the time of sale; and (ii) any compensation received in violation of subsection B of §

3.1-22.80. No person shall be held liable under this section unless that person has actual knowledge of the conduct constituting a violation of this section. Heck, you even have to be aware you are ripping people off!

B. No contract or agreement for payment of a commission, fee, gratuity, or any other form of compensation in connection with any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine shall be enforceable by way of a civil action or defense unless: (i) the contract or agreement is in writing and is signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought; and (ii) the recipient of the compensation provides a written bill of sale for the transaction.
Go back and read the post about contracts. Statute of frauds. New law?? Not hardly. Get it in writing for anything over $10k anyway!

§ 3.1-22.82. Penalty.
Any person who knowingly commits a violation of this section is guilty of a Class 1 misdemeanor.

Here is where some people seem to be getting upset. Yeah they say, “we are willing to keep breaking the law and pay out once in awhile if we get sued, but criminal charges? Just because we are breaking a criminal law against fraud does not mean we should be treated like other criminals!” Uh, yeah, you should. You are not a higher class of con artist then other con artists and frankly, you usually hurt children. Mommy and Daddy can’t afford another horse to replace the broken one they bought that really was worth $20K less and is not sound. No pony for you! Go straight to jail, do not collect your $200. Actually, if you don’t do it often you will probably get probation and a fine. Suck it up or just don’t do it.

Its either going to be this bill or people will have to start using companies to do “Horse Closings” that are very similar to real estate closings. We can have a nice free law or start adding $1,200 onto every sale for the attorneys to do the closings. There is already one VA Law firm that does Horse Closings. They are not making this stuff up. The need is there, the top equine attorney in VA saw that need. They recognized the need for official papers and background checks and signed documents in the sales of horses. It would be a shame if honest dealers had to start paying for closings because a few dishonest ones hate a bill that is against fraud. Pick your poison—everybody pays an extra fee or only the people who are guilty of fraud pay.
If people are afraid they will not have to disclose their actual income for tax purposes if sales are in writing, well boo hoo. We all gotta pay taxes. Not paying taxes is a crime too. Welcome to the real world.

So what does this bill do? It makes you fill out a bill of sale. It makes all transactions open and honest. It gives penalties and remedies for those who rip off or have been ripped off. How is that a bad thing?



Now the comments are open. Maybe I am wrong. Maybe its more then the cost of paper and ink that has people upset. Maybe they have some valid points? Then come and post them and edumicate me. If you are against fraud and against this bill, why?

Wednesday, January 7, 2009

More news from the FL case.

Now remember, charges were only filed because the HSUS promised to pay for all the pigs needs. They made a deal with the local humane society and Yazurlo that if she signed over the pigs to the Humane Society, which they said required them to press charges, they would care for them forever. They said the charges were not "real", it was just a formality before they could release funds. She signed them over, the HSUS ran, the local HS went broke trying to care for the pigs and they gave them back and offered some help.

Don't let this happen to you. Asking for help is just as risky as not asking! If you need help, go local. Do not depend on the HSUS to save the day. If you want to help go local. Do not help the HSUS kill more animals for the sake of a headline.

Here is a new story from back in Nov. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CacHlJunzzE

http://www.news-journalonline.com/NewsJournalOnline/News/Flagler/flaFLAG03010709.htm

January 07, 2009

Pig Tales owner rejects plea deal, pleads not guilty
By FRANK FERNANDEZ
Staff Writer

BUNNELL -- Prosecutors have offered a woman who runs the Pig Tales Sanctuary a deal that includes two years' probation during which time she can't have animals.

But Lory Yazurlo did not take the deal Tuesday in Flagler County court and, instead, pleaded not guilty to a pair of first-degree misdemeanors, cruelty to animals and unlawful abandonment or confinement.

Yazurlo, sitting in her wheelchair, told Judge Sharon Atack she did not have the money to hire an attorney. Atack asked Yazurlo to fill out a financial affidavit.

Yazurlo said after the hearing she was surprised the charges were not dropped Tuesday because she had reached an agreement with the Flagler Humane Society that she could keep caring for the approximately 400 pigs at her sanctuary.

In November the Flagler Humane Society initiated the complaint against Yazurlo, saying pigs at her 20-acre sanctuary in rural Flagler County were "emaciated and malnourished.

"It doesn't make sense," Yazurlo said. "They are giving me all the animals back."

On Dec. 29, humane society director Donna Howard told The News-Journal she had decided to return the pigs to Yazurlo's care after it became clear the only way to remove the pigs from the sanctuary would be to euthanize them.

Howard said the Humane Society would continue to inspect the 20-acre sanctuary.

But she did not appear in court Tuesday, and she could not be reached for comment afterward by The News-Journal.

Assistant State Attorney Scott Westbrook said after the hearing that he had not been contacted by Howard. What would happen if Howard asked for the charges to be dropped?

"I'm not saying if we would go forward or not," Westbrook said. "But, legally, we would not be bound by it."

Westbrook said in these cases, the accused is not usually allowed to keep animals.

"I think a person charged with this should not have control over animals," Westbrook said after the hearing.

Yazurlo said she didn't have any mental issues requiring that she undergo a psychological evaluation, which was part of the agreement Westbrook offered.

"A lot of people consider someone with a lot of animals a hoarder," Yazurlo said outside the court. "It's not like I want any more. I just figure I have to take care of these guys."

frank.fernandez@news-jrnl.com

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Sorry to Interupt your scheduled programing, but 450 animals must die becuase one lawyer cannot google.

In an even more freaksih twist of fate, this woman was charged to the maximum today and nobody bothered to look up the fact the pigs had been returned and an agreement had been signed. So, in essence they are asking that she not be allowed near 450 animals that cannot go anywhere else, who nobody else wants, and will have to be killed. That's how the pigs got rescued.

Google Lory Yazurlo for the full strange story. At this point she has a hearing on Jan 20. She makes too much in Social Security to get a free lawyer and can only pay for a private lawyer if the pigs do not eat anymore. Which would break the law even more. Huh. You can't make this stuff up.

Nobody from the humane society showed up and told the judge anything. Remember my post about lying to the press? This could get interesting. Its certainly not logical or predictable.

Guess FHS is getting 450 for x-mass? No sight of the HSUS who promised to save them all.


December 30, 2008

Abrupt twist in the tale: Woman gets her pigs back
By KENYA WOODARD
Staff Writer

BUNNELL -- The battle between the Flagler Humane Society and Lory Yazurlo over a herd of swine has ended.

The estimated 450 pigs that live at Pig Tales Sanctuary are now back in Yazurlo's custody after more than a month under the care of the humane society.

But the sanctuary founded by Yazurlo in 1995 will no longer operate as it once did, and Yazurlo still faces charges related to the seizure of her animals.

In a phone interview Monday, Flagler Humane Society director Donna Howard said she decided to return the pigs to Yazurlo after it became clear that the only way to remove the pigs from the sanctuary would be to euthanize them.

Howard said she couldn't let that happen.

So the two sides have agreed to "a happy medium," Howard said.

To keep the pigs, Yazurlo must abide by a list of rules that include refraining from taking in any more pigs or adopting them out, neutering all males and tagging the herd, Howard said.

In turn, the humane society will continue to pay for feed one day a week until March and inspect the 20-acre sanctuary on a weekly basis.

Then, the inspection will take place monthly and later be reduced to twice a year, Howard said.

Howard admitted she has reservations about giving up the pigs to Yazurlo. But the plan, coupled with assurances by Yazurlo's attorney that Yazurlo is capable of caring for the animals, has smoothed over those concerns, Howard said.

But if the deal doesn't work out, the humane society will step in and again take control of the pigs, Howard said.

In the meantime, Howard said she and her staff will "play big brother."

"We're going to keep an eye on them," she said. "Hopefully, this will turn out to be a good thing for the pigs."

Reached by phone Monday, Yazurlo said she's satisfied with the arrangement, including the no-pigs-in-or-out rule.

"Pretty much nothing has come or gone in five years," she said.

The inspections are no bother either, she said.

"I've always let them on my property," she said. "I had no problem with them."

The humane society took control of Pig Tales in November after officials discovered many of the pigs were "emaciated and malnourished" and suffering from illnesses, according to reports filed with the Flagler County Sheriff's Office.

Nine pigs were killed with single gunshots to the head during that visit after a veterinarian recommended it because of "their extreme suffering," the reports state.

Another pig in a deteriorated state was euthanized -- not shot -- by the vet the week after the initial visit.

The scene at Pig Tales prompted humane society officials to file complaints of animal cruelty and unlawful confinement of animals against Lory Yazurlo. Those complaints have been referred to the State Attorney's Office. No additional pigs have been killed.

About five pigs recently tested positive for pseudorabies, a contagious viral disease that causes a high mortality rate among infant pigs.

The sanctuary remains under a state-imposed quarantine order after some of the pigs tested positive for the disease in 2003. The state's refusal to lift the quarantine order made removing the pigs from the sanctuary impossible, Howard said.

"Once they told us the pigs couldn't leave the property, there wasn't much we could do," she said.

And the $3,000 weekly bill for the pigs' feed has become a financial burden the humane society could no longer support, she said.

The decision to work with Yazurlo is what's best for the pigs, Howard said.

Yazurlo, however, still faces charges. An arraignment is scheduled for Jan. 6, State Attorney's Office spokeswoman Linda Pruitt said.

Howard said the charges were filed to allow the Humane Society of the United States to offer monetary support to the Flagler organization.

But the HSUS is no longer in the picture and the charges aren't necessary, she said.

"She didn't intend to starve the animals," Howard said. "We're going to work with the courts and tell the judge 'listen, this is where we're at . . .' "

Yazurlo said she's not worried about the case.

"I think I'll be fine," she said.

kenya.woodard@news-jrnl.com

Here's How to Help

If you would like to help, contact:

· Bunnell Feed & Supply, 386-437-2032

· Curley's Place, 386-586-1180

· Charlene Yazurlo, 439-4583 or e-mail at jyazurlo@cfl.rr.com



Now back to your regularly scheduled real world where things like this do not happen. . . .

Remember to read posts from bottom up! The law

A BILL to amend the Code of Virginia by adding in Title 3.1 a chapter numbered 4.9 consisting of sections numbered 3.1-22.78 through 3.1-22.82, relating to the sale of horses by dealers.
Be it enacted by the General Assembly of Virginia:
1. That the Code of Virginia is amended by adding in Title 3.1 a chapter numbered 4.9, consisting of sections numbered 3.1-22.78 through 3.1-22.82, as follows:
Chapter 4.9.
Equine Sales by Dealers.

§ 3.1-22.78. Definitions.
As used in this chapter, unless the context requires a different meaning:
"Dual agent" means a person acting as representative for both the buyer and the seller in any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine. Auction companies shall not be considered dual agents.
"Equine" means a horse of any breed used for racing or showing, including prospective racehorses, breeding prospects, stallions, stallion seasons, broodmares, yearlings, or weanlings, or any interest therein.

§ 3.1-22.79. Written bill of sale required.
A. Any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine over $10,000 shall be: (i) accompanied by a written bill of sale or acknowledgment of purchase and security agreement that includes the purchase price; and (ii) signed by both the purchaser and the seller or their agent or, in a transaction solely relating to a season or fractional interest in the stallion, the syndicate manager or stallion manager.
B. If the equine is sold, purchased, or transferred at public auction, the requirements of this section may also be satisfied by the issuance of an auction receipt generated by the auction house, and signed by the purchaser or his agent. An agent who signs an auction receipt on behalf of the principal shall do so only if authorized in writing. When presented with such authorization, all other parties to the transaction may presume that an agent signing on behalf of the principal is authorized to act for the principal. For transactions at public auction, this section shall not require disclosure of the reserves, the identity of the principals, or the auctioneer's commissions.

§ 3.1-22.80. Dual agency; consent required; agency; consignor; disclosure of compensation.
A. Any person acting as a dual agent in any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine shall acquire the prior written consent of both the buyer and the seller.
B. Any person acting as a dual agent, consignor, or agent for either a purchaser or a seller in a transaction involving the sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine who may receive compensation, in any form, with a value in excess of $500 shall disclose the payment in writing to both the purchaser and seller; and acquire the written consent for such compensation from each principal for whom the agent is acting.
C. Any person acting as a dual agent, consignor, or agent for either a purchaser or a seller in a transaction involving the sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine shall, upon request by the principal, furnish copies of all financial records and financial documents in the possession or control of the agent pertaining to the transaction with the principal. Financial records shall not include the agent's or owner's work product used to internally evaluate the equine.

§ 3.1-22.81. Civil action for violation of chapter.
A. Any person who violates this chapter shall be civilly liable for damages in treble the amount of the damages sustained by the complaining party. The prevailing party in any litigation under this section shall be entitled to an award of costs of the suit, reasonable litigation expenses, and attorney's fees. As used in this section, treble damages shall equal three times the sum of: (i) the difference, if any, between the price paid for the equine and the actual value of the equine at the time of sale; and (ii) any compensation received in violation of subsection B of § 3.1-22.80. No person shall be held liable under this section unless that person has actual knowledge of the conduct constituting a violation of this section.
B. No contract or agreement for payment of a commission, fee, gratuity, or any other form of compensation in connection with any sale, purchase, or transfer of an equine shall be enforceable by way of a civil action or defense unless: (i) the contract or agreement is in writing and is signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought; and (ii) the recipient of the compensation provides a written bill of sale for the transaction.

§ 3.1-22.82. Penalty.
Any person who knowingly commits a violation of this section is guilty of a Class 1 misdemeanor.

Next we will look at each section in detail. It wont look scary at all when we are done!

Are you for Fraud or Against it? New laws debated.

The laws of agency are common law principals that date back to before there were any United States. In “olden times” there were no cell phones, no e-mail and no internet. In fact, there were not even any cars or methods of rapid communication. This meant that if you wanted to do business, you had to hire others to represent you since you could only be in one place at one time. Thus, the laws of agency were created out of need and still exist because without laws, people will just rip you off and leave you broke.

Here is a primer on agency in plain English as it relates to real estate. http://www.ired.com/buymyself/agency/970312.htm It is actually pretty much how agency relates to any situation, because, frankly, an agent is an agent. Real estate agents must be licensed and often have their own code of ethics, but although horse dealers are not real estate agents, they still are bound by the laws of agency.

Now we are going to pick a state that is considering enacting laws to cover the sales of horses. Except, we are really not going to be looking at new laws—the laws of agency are already on the books and already apply—we are just looking at extra words so that everybody clearly understands that these ancient rules DO apply to horses because a lot of horses cost more then a house. One of the things these laws do is include attorneys fees so that the person who was just been ripped off for $20,000 does not have to pay $30,000 to try and get her money back. In certain cases of fraud there is a small criminal charge. Like the one that is already there in another section. Nothing new, just the same thing in a different section of the code so its clear that it applies to horses. Judicial clerks could google horse+agency+fraud and find the right code. And if you commit a criminal act, shouldn’t you be punished? Why would anyone argue against that? How does less crime cut into their profits?

These types of laws have already been passed in several states. Life as we know it did not end. The sky did not fall. Things went along pretty much as they had. Now a new bill is being debated for Virginia. Oddly, many are against it. They are against a law that is already the law. The new section’s sole purpose is to make sure its easy to enforce the laws against fraud in horse sales. There is much debate going on, because, I guess, a lot of people are for fraud?

Some of the pro-fraud people will no doubt be very cross with me for being in support of anti-fraud legislation. They will write nasty messages that they will never hire me! Well, that’s OK. See, I am a lawyer. In the best case scenario I can only represent half of all the available clients. I am not Wal-mart. I cannot run all the other lawyers out of business or there could be no lawsuits for me to try. I only have to please a small fraction of the people all the time and I am the one who is suing you if you violate the law, so it’s the other guys business I want anyway. And I practice in SC. We have the toughest consumer protection laws around. If the things these laws addressed were to happen in my state the guilty would not only have to pay me for my services, but all the damages are tripled. I can make much more money suing crooks down here. So, not only is VA not the state were I make my living, but if it were, I would be on the other side. So save the threats of never hiring me for someone who actually cares. If you are pro-fraud, the person you stole from needs a lawyer too. That lawyer still will not be me, but if the pay is high enough, the lawyer will always appear. And we do not scare easy. Frown away.


I grew up in Northern Va. I saw with my own eyes that fraud and theft and deceit were not an uncommon occurrence in the horse business. I certainly saw honest horse people trying to make an honest living, but they had to work 3 times as hard to make half as much then the competition who would lie, cheat and steal. Honest horse folk drop out of the race leaving the pool even more concentrated with the bad eggs. I was told in no uncertain terms that if I wanted to play in the Hunter Jumper world I had to drug horses, cheat clients and do whatever I was told and never say anything was wrong. I didn’t shut up then and I won’t shut up now. It was bad, probably worse then you even know. I saved evidence from those days in case someone, somewhere at some time actually cared enough to do something about the cheaters. The fact I still have those VHS tapes laying around should tell you how bad I thought it was.

However, there were those that worked very hard and did nothing wrong. I do not paint all horsemen with the same brush, but as far as I know the good ones were not pro-fraud then and are not pro–fraud now. I also knew many good and honest horse people who were perpetually broke. Hmmmm.

Next up is the actual proposed code. I assume some of the discomfort about the proposed laws must be due to not understanding it or understanding how it applies. Clearly people that understood it would not be signing their names to petitions to allow fraud. That makes no sense.