Lets breakdown this law line by line. Now mind you, this is only my interpretation of the law, only a court can decide what it really means. Then we will make up a defendant and try to apply the law. My comments in italics. Some day I will learn HTML, but for now italics are the only thing that transfers from word to blog unaltered.
Title 47 - Animals, Livestock and Poultry
CHAPTER 1.
CRUELTY TO ANIMALS
SECTION 47-1-10. Definitions.
As used in this chapter:
(1) "Animal" means a living vertebrate creature except a homo sapien.
That’s pretty clear. ALL animals except humans. But it does not really separate animals we want to have around from animals we don’t. Are we talking about domestic animals or just any animal on your property?
(2) "Sustenance" means adequate food provided at suitable intervals of quantities of wholesome foodstuff suitable for the species and age, sufficient to maintain a reasonable level of nutrition to allow for proper growth and weight and adequate water provided with constant access to a supply of clean, fresh, and potable water provided in a suitable manner for the species.
Wait, what? Do they want adequate water or water at all times? Does that mean a dog in a crate must have water 24/7? If you crate your dog without water, do you feel like you should be criminally charged? As water that has been in the hot SC sun all day still clean and fresh? What is clean? Is a stream clean or do you have to test it? A pond? Is a pond clean? I think the fed section is pretty clear after they get past reasonable because they do define what the goal should be. If your animal is too skinny due to lack of food it was not reasonable.
(3) "Shelter" means shelter that reasonably may be expected to protect the animal from physical suffering or impairment of health due to exposure to the elements or adverse weather.
No way this can be interpreted to be anything but a right to shelter for the animal. Shelter is good. I am all for shelter, but it is not necessary and no doubt all the Ag people exempted do not supply shelter in a feet lot or at pasture. Lets face it, Cattle are woodland creatures like deer. If you see them outside grazing during the day they are being asked to do what they are not designed for. They do not even sweat. But is that cruel or negligence? On the other hand, this sort of makes it law that your animals must be inside during a storm. They must be protected from adverse weather. Not just having it available, but making sure they use it.
SECTION 47-1-20. Acts of agents imputed to corporations.
The knowledge and acts of agents and persons employed by corporations in regard to animals transported, owned or employed by or in the custody of such corporations shall be held to be the acts and knowledge of such corporations.
SECTION 47-1-30. Repealed by 1998 Act No. 367, Section 9, eff May 27, 1998.
SECTION 47-1-40. Ill-treatment of animals generally.
(A) Whoever knowingly or intentionally overloads, overdrives, overworks, ill-treats any animal, deprives any animal of necessary sustenance or shelter, inflicts unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal, or by omission or commission knowingly or intentionally causes these things to be done, for every offense is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment not exceeding sixty days or by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars nor more than five hundred dollars, or both, for a first offense; by imprisonment not exceeding ninety days or by a fine not exceeding eight hundred dollars, or both, for a second offense; or by imprisonment not exceeding two years or by a fine not exceeding two thousand dollars, or both, for a third or subsequent offense. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a first offense under this subsection shall be tried in magistrate's or municipal court.
This law applies a knowing and intentional standard. So if you are just stupid and think animals do not need to eat you are not guilty. Some states take the knowingly out. Its hard to prove what people knew. I am not saying this is a bad thing. I think a criminal law should have a mens rhea or intentional element, but where or how do we know what people should have known to not do stupid things? Nobody is required to take a class, get a license on care or take a test. You just go get an animal. I suppose a common sense standard is applied, but common sense is not that common.
(B) Whoever tortures, torments, needlessly mutilates, cruelly kills, or inflicts excessive or repeated unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal or by omission or commission causes the acts to be done for any of the offenses is guilty of a felony and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment of not less than one hundred eighty days and not to exceed five years and by a fine of five thousand dollars.
This is the cruelty part. But what animals does it apply to? Mice? Are mouse traps illegal? They are cruel. What about poison? What kind of killing is not cruelly?
(C) This section does not apply to fowl, accepted animal husbandry practices of farm operations and the training of animals, the practice of veterinary medicine, agricultural practices, forestry and silvacultural practices, wildlife management practices, or activity authorized by Title 50, including an activity authorized by the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources or an exercise designed for training dogs for hunting, if repeated contact with a dog or dogs and another animal does not occur during this training exercise.
And here is a mindboggling list of exclusions. Fowl is beneath our compassion. And TRAINING??? That’s an odd thing to exclude. Spur a horse until it drips blood but its OK because its for training? What about whipping a dressage horse for an hour non-stop. That is excluded? And here we have agriculture excluded because we are really not talking about ALL non human animals—we are talking about certain non-human animals who’s right exceed their economic value as meat or fiber or other uses. Some accepted practices clearly violate the first 2 clauses. Wildlife, sorry, you do not get protection. So what is really left? Pets and livestock so far gone even the exemption does not apply. I am not sure how this law might apply to cruel wildlife management practices or cruel sport practices.
SECTION 47-1-50. Cruel work; carriage in vehicles; penalties.
(A) An owner, a possessor, or a person having the charge or custody of an animal may not:
(1) cruelly drive or work it when unfit for labor;
(2) carry it, or cause it to be carried, in or upon a vehicle or otherwise in an unnecessarily cruel or inhumane manner.
(B) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished for each offense in the manner prescribed in Section 47-1-40(A).
You can see how these laws evolved over time to address specific concerns. Carriage horses have their own clause, but they are pretty are these days. This is actually addressed in the first clause, but this clause might be a holdover form the days when many horses were draft animals.
SECTION 47-1-60. Cutting muscles of tails of horses, asses, mules, mares, or geldings prohibited.
Any person who (a) cuts the tissue or muscle of the tail of any horse, ass, mule, mare or gelding, or otherwise operates upon it in any manner for the purpose or with the effect of altering the natural carriage of the tail, except when such cutting or operation is necessary for the health or life of the animal, as certified to in writing by a licensed veterinarian, (b) causes, procures or knowingly permits such cutting or operation to be done or (c) assists in or is voluntarily present at such cutting or operation shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
Any person convicted of violating any of the provisions of this section shall be fined not less than fifty nor more than one hundred dollars or imprisoned not less than fifteen nor more than thirty days.
Again, when did we stop cutting tails? Docking is out for horses, but not for dogs. Random cause driven laws. One cause that was popular in days gone by was the methods used on saddle seat horses to get a desired tail set. It made it in here. But it’s not the cutting off of part of an animal that is the problem, its just certain animals. Cut off bits of your dog all you want. And notice the categories. Are stallions the horses? Or would horses not naturally include mares and geldings? Can you cut fillies and colts?
SECTION 47-1-70. Abandonment of animals; penalties; hunting dog exception.
(A) A person may not abandon an animal. As used in this section "abandonment" is defined as deserting, forsaking, or intending to give up absolutely an animal without securing another owner or without providing the necessities of life. "Necessities of life" includes:
(1) adequate water which means a constant access to a supply of clean, fresh, and potable water provided in a suitable manner for the species;
(2) adequate food which means provision at suitable intervals of quantities of wholesome foodstuff suitable for the species and age, sufficient to maintain a reasonable level of nutrition to allow for proper growth and weight;
(3) adequate shelter which means shelter that reasonably may be expected to protect the animal from physical suffering or impairment of health due to exposure to the elements or adverse weather.
(B) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be fined not less than two hundred nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned not more than thirty days, or both. Offenses under this section must be tried in the magistrate's or municipal court.
(C) A hunting dog that is positively identifiable in accordance with Section 47-3-510 or Section 47-3-530 is exempt from this section.
Wait, wasn’t all this already covered in the first 2 sections? I think they mean to address literally dumping an animal off or leaving it completely. What is the distinction here and how does it apply to facts to make it a worse offense then the first one warranting harsher penalties?
SECTION 47-1-75. Immunity from civil and criminal liability.
Any person, including a person licensed to practice veterinary medicine, or an animal control officer or agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or any society incorporated for that purpose, who in good faith and without compensation for services provided, acting without malice, recklessness, or gross negligence, renders emergency care or treatment to a domestic animal which is abandoned, ill, injured, or in distress related to an accident or disaster shall not be liable or subject to any civil or criminal liability for any injuries or harm to such animal resulting from the rendering of such care or treatment, or any act or failure to act to provide or arrange for further medical treatment or care for such animal.
I hate these things. No the laws, but the wording. Any person includes any person, but then having a list follow it makes me think NOT any person but just those listed.
SECTION 47-1-80. Destruction of abandoned infirm animal.
Any agent or officer of the Department of Health and Environmental Control or police officer or officer of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or of any society duly incorporated for that purpose may lawfully destroy, or cause to be destroyed, any animal found abandoned and not properly cared for, appearing to be glandered, injured or diseased past recovery for any useful purpose.
I am not sure what glandered is. I could look it up, but they could have just used a word that is understandable. And “appearing to be past recovery for any useful purpose” makes me cringe. That covers a whole lot of pets and pasture puffs. Plus the definition of abandoned is not properly cared for, but its still not defined as anything else. If they drive by my house and see a lame old horse that I just got and is skinny, can they just kill it?
SECTION 47-1-90. Overloading and length of confinement of animals in railroad cars.
No railroad company in the carrying or transportation of animals shall overload the cars nor permit the animals to be confined in cars for a longer period than thirty-six consecutive hours without unloading them for rest, water and feeding for a period of at least five consecutive hours, unless prevented from so unloading by storm or other accidental causes beyond the control of such railroad company; provided, however, that when animals shall be carried in cars in which they can and do have proper food, water and space and opportunity for rest, the foregoing provisions in regard to their being unloaded shall not apply.
In estimating such confinement the time during which the animals have been confined without such rest on connecting roads from which they are received shall be included, it being the intent of this section to prohibit their continuous confinement beyond the period of thirty-six hours, except upon the contingencies hereinbefore stated.
Um. . . do a lot of shipping railroad cars lately?
SECTION 47-1-100. Care of animals unloaded during transit.
Animals unloaded as required by Section 47-1-90 shall be properly fed, watered and sheltered during such rest by the owner or person having the custody thereof or, in case of his default in so doing, then by the railroad company transporting such animals at the expense of the owner or person in custody thereof; and the company shall, in such case, have a lien upon such animals for food, care and custody furnished and shall not be liable for any detention of such animals.
SECTION 47-1-110. Violations of Sections 47-1-90 and 47-1-100.
Any company or the owner or custodian of such animals who shall fail to comply with the provisions of Sections 47-1-90 and 47-1-100 shall, for each and every such offense, if found guilty, be fined not less than fifty nor more than five hundred dollars, in any court of competent jurisdiction.
Hey, here’s an idea. Lets see this updated to trucks and trailers, huh?
SECTION 47-1-120. Custody of animals in charge of arrested persons.
When a person arrested is, at the time of the arrest, in charge of an animal, an agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, may take charge of the animal and deposit the animal in a safe place of custody or deliver the animal into the possession of the police or sheriff of the county or place where the arrest was made, who shall assume the custody of the animal; and all necessary expenses incurred in taking charge of the animal shall be a lien thereon.
I remember a case about 15 years ago. Police knock down door and raid house. The dog barks at police. They crack him over the head with baton and knock him out. They take him to animal control and refuse to give him back and plan on putting him down. They had the wrong house. There was no crime gong on inside that house at all. Even after this is discovered they will not give dog back. So one night dog is stolen from shelter. All letters to the editor are in favor of the dog thieves.
But back to the law. It costs $$ to bail out an animal. It is unclear whether a friend or relative can go get the animal immediately.
SECTION 47-1-125. Coloring or dying animals prohibited; sale or distribution of certain young animals prohibited; penalty.
(1) It is unlawful for any person to dye or color artificially any animal or fowl, including but not limited to rabbits, baby chickens, and ducklings, or to bring any dyed or colored animal or fowl into this State.
(2) It is unlawful for any person to sell, offer for sale or give away as merchandising premiums, baby chickens, ducklings or other fowl under four weeks of age or rabbits under two months of age to be used as pets, toys or retail premiums.
(3) This section shall not be construed to apply to any animal or fowl, including but not limited to rabbits, baby chickens and ducklings to be used or raised for agricultural purposes by persons with proper facilities to care for them or for poultry or livestock exhibitions.
(4) Any person violating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction shall be fined not more than two hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days.
This is all stuff dating back about 50 years. Easter chicks and ducks and bunnies were all over dyed in Easter colors. I like the juxtaposition of ITS BAD bit its NOT BAD if you are a farmer. Because Ag chicks can be sent in the mail and sent very young and apparently any color you want. Who is the protection f or and what standard is used to decide what is humane and what is not? Because I am kind of thinking I’d rather be a young pink pet chick then the one headed for the poultry house.
SECTION 47-1-130. Arrest for violation of laws prohibiting cruelty to animals.
Any person violating the laws in relation to cruelty to animals may be arrested and held, without warrant, in the same manner as in the case of persons found breaking the peace.
I wonder why no warrant?
SECTION 47-1-140. Care of animals after arrest of person in charge.
The person making the arrest, with or without warrant, shall use reasonable diligence to give notice to the owner of the animals found in the charge or custody of the person arrested, if the person is not the owner, and shall care and provide properly for the animals. The person making such arrest shall have a lien on the animals for the expense of such care and provision. But if such person making the arrest be an agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or other society incorporated for that purpose, the provisions of Section 47-1-120 shall apply in lieu of the provisions of this section. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, an animal may be seized preceding an arrest and pursuant to Section 47-1-150.
Yeah, the SC Supreme Court read this to require a warrant after all and a hearing. They basically voided this and said use 47-1-150 instead.
SECTION 47-1-150. Issuance of search warrant; purpose of section; motions regarding custody of animal; notice; care, disposal of, or return of animal.
(A) When complaint is made on oath or affirmation to any magistrate authorized to issue warrants in criminal cases that the complainant believes and has reasonable cause to believe that the laws in relation to cruelty to animals have been or are being violated in any particular building or place, such magistrate, if satisfied that there is reasonable cause for such belief, shall issue a search warrant authorizing any sheriff, deputy sheriff, deputy state constable, constable or police officer to search such building or place; but no search shall be made after sunset, unless specially authorized by the magistrate upon satisfactory cause shown. If an animal is seized pursuant to this section and the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty of Animals, or other society incorporated for that purpose is involved with the seizure, the animal may be held pending criminal disposition of the case at a facility maintained or contracted by that agency.
(B) The purpose of this section is to provide a means by which a neglected or mistreated animal can be:
(1) removed from its present custody, or
(2) made the subject of an order to provide care, issued to its owner by the magistrate or municipal judge, any law enforcement officer, or any agent of the county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or any society incorporated for that purpose and given protection and an appropriate and humane disposition made.
(C) Any law enforcement officer or any agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or any society incorporated for that purpose may move before a magistrate for an order to:
(1) lawfully take custody of any animal found neglected or cruelly treated by removing the animal from its present location if deemed by the court that removal is necessary to prevent further suffering or ill-treatment, or
(2) order the owner of any animal found neglected or cruelly treated to provide certain care to the animal at the owner's expense without removal of the animal from its present location, and shall forthwith petition the magistrate or municipal judge of the county or municipality wherein the animal is found for a hearing, to be set within twenty-four hours after the date of seizure of the animal or issuance of the order to provide care and held not more than two days after the setting of such date, to determine whether the owner, if known, is able to provide adequately for the animal and is fit to have custody of the animal. The hearing shall be concluded, and the court order entered the date the hearing is commenced. No fee shall be charged for the filing of the petition. Nothing herein is intended to require court action for the taking into custody and making proper disposition of stray or abandoned animals as lawfully performed by animal control agents.
The recent case did not really apply the “or”. The “or’ is what they had to go on but the court decided the “or” was an “and”. And thus the importance of every letter and punctuation in a code.
(D) The officer or agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, taking charge of any animal pursuant to the provisions of this section shall have written notice served prior to the hearing set forth in subsection (C)(2), upon the owner of the animal, if he is known and is residing in the county where the animal was taken. The sheriff of the county shall not charge a fee for service of such notice. If the owner of the animal is known but is residing outside of the county wherein the animal was taken, notice of the hearing shall be by publication.
(E) If any seized animal held by court order at the owner's premises is removed without notification to the investigating agency, or if an animal becomes sick or dies, and the owner or custodian fails to immediately notify the investigating agency, the owner must be held in contempt of court and fined up to the penalties provided by law.
(F) The officer or agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, taking charge of an animal as provided for in this section shall provide for the animal until either:
(1) The owner is adjudged by the court to be able to provide adequately for, and have custody of, the animal, in which case the animal shall be returned to the owner upon payment for the care and provision of the animal while in the agent's or officer's custody; or
(2) The animal is turned over to the officer or agent as provided in Section 47-1-170 and a humane disposition of the animal is made.
(G) If the court determines that the owner is able to provide adequately for, and have custody of the animal, the order shall provide that the animal in possession of the officer or agent be claimed and removed by the owner within seven days after the date of the order.
In reality these things take years and the board bills add up to huge amounts of $$$. However, in this state it take so much to get animals seized there are rarely mistakes and so far nobody has been wrongly accused.
SECTION 47-1-160. Disposition of fines.
All fines collected for violations of this chapter must be distributed as follows:
(1) If the trial court finds that there was a nonprofit animal humane organization in the municipality or county materially involved in or aiding in the prosecution of the violation, one-half of the fine must be distributed to the nonprofit animal humane organization and the remaining one-half must be distributed as is otherwise provided by law.
This is great. It’s a way to fund rescues. Does your state do this?
(2) If there is no finding of material involvement or aiding in the prosecution of the violation by a nonprofit animal humane organization, the fine must be distributed as is provided by law.
SECTION 47-1-170. Penalties for violations of chapter.
The owner or person having charge or custody of an animal cruelly used who is convicted of any violation of this chapter forfeits ownership, charge, or custody of the animal and at the discretion of the court, the person who is charged with or convicted of a violation of this chapter must be ordered to pay costs incurred to care for the animal and related expenses.
SECTION 47-1-200. Requirements for transfer of animals and importation or exportation of dog or cat; penalties for violations.
(A) During transportation, an animal must not be confined in one area for more than twenty-four consecutive hours without being adequately exercised, rested, fed, and watered. The time may be extended reasonably when an act of God causes a delay. The animal must be provided adequate space and ventilation.
(B) A dog or cat under eight weeks of age must not be imported or exported without being accompanied by its dam.
(C) A person who violates the provisions of this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be fined not less than two hundred nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days, or both.
SECTION 47-1-210. Live animals as prizes; exceptions; penalties.
(A) It is unlawful to give away a live animal including, but not limited to, a fish, bird, fowl, or reptile, as a prize for, or as an inducement to enter, any contest, game, or other competition, or as an inducement to enter a place of amusement, or for these species to be used as an incentive to enter into any business agreement if the offer made was for the purpose of attracting trade.
(B) Nothing in this section may be construed to prohibit an auction or raffle of a live animal including, but not limited to, a fish, bird, fowl, or reptile. Further, the giving away or the testing of game or fowl for breeding purposes only is lawful and is not prohibited by this section as an incentive to enter into a business agreement if the person giving away or testing game or fowl is engaged in that trade.
(C) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished for each separate offense by a fine not to exceed three hundred dollars or imprisonment not to exceed thirty days, or both.
(D) This section does not apply when a live animal is given away as follows:
(1) by individuals or organizations operating in conjunction with a cooperative extension education program or agricultural vocational program sanctioned by the State Department of Education or local school districts;
(2) by individuals or organizations operating in conjunction with field trials approved by the Department of Natural Resources; or
(3) by kennels that advertise in national publications in regard to dogs that are registered with the United Kennel Club or the American Kennel Club.
Now this is just bizarre. That gold fish you won at the fair? GIVE IT BACK AND RUN! Why is it Ok for the AKC kennels to do it? Not sure what the basis for this is, but I am all for giving animals away. Lets ban selling them and see if their welfare improves?
Friday, February 27, 2009
Thursday, February 26, 2009
Part II: Animal Rights are Already Here.
Ok. I have been putting off posting on animal cruelty and welfare because it is highly unlikely I won’t piss someone off. I was chicken. I admit it. I tried to find a way to make everyone happy. I just can’t find it. So now you will be stuck with too much information and of course I will start with a history lesson. My blog. My thoughts.
Regulating the treatment of animals is not a modern concept. It’s in the bible. That’s pretty old. Lot of primitive cultures had certain ways of telling their people what was allowed and what was not. For example, the bible says in what manner animals for food may be killed. I am talking Old Testament here. Part of Kosher is a clean, humane slaughter. First argument; but that was religion and not a law. Wrong, religious beliefs were the law back then. You violate a religious practice and you might get stoned to death. There was no separation of church and state in a really big way. Old Testament does not wait for you to go to hell. They punish you themselves.
However, even back in biblical times the treatment of animals was a hodgepodge of completely random and capricious rules. Some eastern cultures forbid the intentional killing of any living thing—even an insect. Not so in our Judeo-Christian belief system. Kill the steer cleanly with no suffering, stay away from the pigs, fish have no rules unless they have a shell and if its vermin you kill it as fast as you can by any means. That is not a logical system. And its purpose is unclear. I am going to stick to the Judeo-Christian belief system because that is what out modern moral and legal code is derived from. At least for now.
In between biblical times and modern times the role and treatment of animals has mostly been all over the place. Prohibitions on treating animals poorly may have been for economic reasons, moral reasons, or just plain pride in a job well done. At times animals had no protections from ill abuse, but were subject to criminal prosecutions for moral failings. In the Middle Ages and right past the renaissance animals could be and were tried for crimes. If a human was tried for bestiality the animal was right there next to him and tried too. Dogs, cats, rats and all other creatures, even bugs, had court appointed lawyers to make sure they were guilty before they were executed for their crimes. For a long period of time an animal was entitled to much better legal representation than a human. I am just recounting theses facts. I am not even going to begin to try and explain it. Let’s just say morality was so important back then that even a rat had to act according to human social norms. And The Rule of Law was new and sort of cool so maybe they just got carried away.
The basis of our American modern anti-cruelty statutes is about 150 years old. It was considered bad for the morals of women and children to have to see animals beaten to death in the streets of the cities, so the first modern laws were drafted. The laws were not to protect animals, but to protect humans from having to witness such gruesome scenes. The constitutional basis for state police action was to protect the moral good—an allowed use of state powers. Over the years it was to protect moral good and human health and safety. But the key is that it was all about us and not about them. Then, due to changes in the political system, our nation laws started getting written that protected animals from cruelty for the animal’s sake.
Groups of concerned citizens could lobby for laws to be changed. People now had pets and saw some animals in a different light. Women got the vote and they became actively involved in “safe, feminine” causes like animal welfare acts. So on that day when the first anti-cruelty statute was written and put into a code section just for animals like the SC one below, animals had rights.
Commence freaking out now. I mean, we all know that Animal Rights is a future thing that we either support or fear, but most of us are completely blind to the fact AR are not new and are already in place. Isn’t that what PETA and the HSUS want? Certainly I am not lumping supporters of animal welfare among those that support animal rights! Yes, I am. A “right” is something granted by force of law and if there are laws granting certain animals the right to have minimum basic needs met, they have a RIGHT to those needs. They have a right to welfare standards set out by law. They have people assigned that can ask a court to enforce that right. They have rights already, so let that sink in.
Now, which animals have rights and what rights they have is controlled by both state and federal law. There are a lot of laws out there. The easiest way to get a handle on understanding what we are dealing with is to break it up into 2 kinds of crimes—neglect and cruelty. Neglect can be just ignorance or less then ideal conditions while cruelty is usually, but not always, intentional and outrageous. They often carry more severe punishments for intentional cruelty and there is less disagreement in what constitutes cruelty then neglect. Less, but not none.
The laws themselves often create completely artificial divisions between animals. They are based on which animals we have emotional feelings for and which ones we do not care for. They also exclude lots of common farming practices because while we may be outraged at a starving puppy, we do not want that to interfere with out hamburger for dinner. And fur and 4 legs ranks higher in most cases then other life forms, unless they are vermin and then we apply a completely different standard. If they are wild and endangered yet another standard is applied.
There is absolutely no rhyme or reason behind these laws if the object is to protect animals from unnecessary suffering. They reflect a world view of a Disney animation team as much as they do any logical distinctions. So, in many ways they are just like a lot of other laws. Its illegal because we say so, now go eat your pudding. We make it up and then justify it later. As long as most of us agree, it’s all fine and dandy. Because fish can’t feel pain anyway, right? No, not really. I eat raw oysters. That means I eat them ALIVE and they die when they hit my stomach acid. I am pretty sure if I quaffed down a few live kittens I would not be invited to your next dinner party.
So besides the fact that everything we think we know is probably wrong, it may also be unconstitutional to give animals rights without amending the constitution in some way. I know that is pretty far out there, but people go to jail for violating the rights of a non-human animal. But only some animals and some activities are illegal with absolutely no real standard to apply and no real state interest to allow police action. Animals are not supposed to have rights. If they do then don’t all animals have them? It sort of seems like the definition of arbitrary and capricious to me and in many cases the application of these laws is as arbitrary as I can possibly imagine. For example, say you have a pet pig and someone claims you are neglecting it. Just walk outside, shoot it with arrows until its good and dead and eat it. Problem solved. No pig no rights no case. And bacon is yummy. Huh? Or your horses are fine but the rats on our farm and in poor shape. Didn’t the statute say ALL non human animals? But what do they really mean? Is it vague? Like too vague? Like maybe void for vagueness vague?
Here is the SC code. Read it. Really read it. Who is it designed to protect? Who is it designed to punish? Can you see the difference between neglect and cruelty? Can you actually apply this law or see a way to comply with it?
Title 47 - Animals, Livestock and Poultry
CHAPTER 1.
CRUELTY TO ANIMALS
SECTION 47-1-10. Definitions.
As used in this chapter:
(1) "Animal" means a living vertebrate creature except a homo sapien.
(2) "Sustenance" means adequate food provided at suitable intervals of quantities of wholesome foodstuff suitable for the species and age, sufficient to maintain a reasonable level of nutrition to allow for proper growth and weight and adequate water provided with constant access to a supply of clean, fresh, and potable water provided in a suitable manner for the species.
(3) "Shelter" means shelter that reasonably may be expected to protect the animal from physical suffering or impairment of health due to exposure to the elements or adverse weather.
SECTION 47-1-20. Acts of agents imputed to corporations.
The knowledge and acts of agents and persons employed by corporations in regard to animals transported, owned or employed by or in the custody of such corporations shall be held to be the acts and knowledge of such corporations.
SECTION 47-1-30. Repealed by 1998 Act No. 367, Section 9, eff May 27, 1998.
SECTION 47-1-40. Ill-treatment of animals generally.
(A) Whoever knowingly or intentionally overloads, overdrives, overworks, ill-treats any animal, deprives any animal of necessary sustenance or shelter, inflicts unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal, or by omission or commission knowingly or intentionally causes these things to be done, for every offense is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment not exceeding sixty days or by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars nor more than five hundred dollars, or both, for a first offense; by imprisonment not exceeding ninety days or by a fine not exceeding eight hundred dollars, or both, for a second offense; or by imprisonment not exceeding two years or by a fine not exceeding two thousand dollars, or both, for a third or subsequent offense. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a first offense under this subsection shall be tried in magistrate's or municipal court.
(B) Whoever tortures, torments, needlessly mutilates, cruelly kills, or inflicts excessive or repeated unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal or by omission or commission causes the acts to be done for any of the offenses is guilty of a felony and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment of not less than one hundred eighty days and not to exceed five years and by a fine of five thousand dollars.
(C) This section does not apply to fowl, accepted animal husbandry practices of farm operations and the training of animals, the practice of veterinary medicine, agricultural practices, forestry and silvacultural practices, wildlife management practices, or activity authorized by Title 50, including an activity authorized by the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources or an exercise designed for training dogs for hunting, if repeated contact with a dog or dogs and another animal does not occur during this training exercise.
SECTION 47-1-50. Cruel work; carriage in vehicles; penalties.
(A) An owner, a possessor, or a person having the charge or custody of an animal may not:
(1) cruelly drive or work it when unfit for labor;
(2) carry it, or cause it to be carried, in or upon a vehicle or otherwise in an unnecessarily cruel or inhumane manner.
(B) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished for each offense in the manner prescribed in Section 47-1-40(A).
SECTION 47-1-60. Cutting muscles of tails of horses, asses, mules, mares, or geldings prohibited.
Any person who (a) cuts the tissue or muscle of the tail of any horse, ass, mule, mare or gelding, or otherwise operates upon it in any manner for the purpose or with the effect of altering the natural carriage of the tail, except when such cutting or operation is necessary for the health or life of the animal, as certified to in writing by a licensed veterinarian, (b) causes, procures or knowingly permits such cutting or operation to be done or (c) assists in or is voluntarily present at such cutting or operation shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
Any person convicted of violating any of the provisions of this section shall be fined not less than fifty nor more than one hundred dollars or imprisoned not less than fifteen nor more than thirty days.
SECTION 47-1-70. Abandonment of animals; penalties; hunting dog exception.
(A) A person may not abandon an animal. As used in this section "abandonment" is defined as deserting, forsaking, or intending to give up absolutely an animal without securing another owner or without providing the necessities of life. "Necessities of life" includes:
(1) adequate water which means a constant access to a supply of clean, fresh, and potable water provided in a suitable manner for the species;
(2) adequate food which means provision at suitable intervals of quantities of wholesome foodstuff suitable for the species and age, sufficient to maintain a reasonable level of nutrition to allow for proper growth and weight;
(3) adequate shelter which means shelter that reasonably may be expected to protect the animal from physical suffering or impairment of health due to exposure to the elements or adverse weather.
(B) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be fined not less than two hundred nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned not more than thirty days, or both. Offenses under this section must be tried in the magistrate's or municipal court.
(C) A hunting dog that is positively identifiable in accordance with Section 47-3-510 or Section 47-3-530 is exempt from this section.
SECTION 47-1-75. Immunity from civil and criminal liability.
Any person, including a person licensed to practice veterinary medicine, or an animal control officer or agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or any society incorporated for that purpose, who in good faith and without compensation for services provided, acting without malice, recklessness, or gross negligence, renders emergency care or treatment to a domestic animal which is abandoned, ill, injured, or in distress related to an accident or disaster shall not be liable or subject to any civil or criminal liability for any injuries or harm to such animal resulting from the rendering of such care or treatment, or any act or failure to act to provide or arrange for further medical treatment or care for such animal.
SECTION 47-1-80. Destruction of abandoned infirm animal.
Any agent or officer of the Department of Health and Environmental Control or police officer or officer of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or of any society duly incorporated for that purpose may lawfully destroy, or cause to be destroyed, any animal found abandoned and not properly cared for, appearing to be glandered, injured or diseased past recovery for any useful purpose.
SECTION 47-1-90. Overloading and length of confinement of animals in railroad cars.
No railroad company in the carrying or transportation of animals shall overload the cars nor permit the animals to be confined in cars for a longer period than thirty-six consecutive hours without unloading them for rest, water and feeding for a period of at least five consecutive hours, unless prevented from so unloading by storm or other accidental causes beyond the control of such railroad company; provided, however, that when animals shall be carried in cars in which they can and do have proper food, water and space and opportunity for rest, the foregoing provisions in regard to their being unloaded shall not apply.
In estimating such confinement the time during which the animals have been confined without such rest on connecting roads from which they are received shall be included, it being the intent of this section to prohibit their continuous confinement beyond the period of thirty-six hours, except upon the contingencies hereinbefore stated.
SECTION 47-1-100. Care of animals unloaded during transit.
Animals unloaded as required by Section 47-1-90 shall be properly fed, watered and sheltered during such rest by the owner or person having the custody thereof or, in case of his default in so doing, then by the railroad company transporting such animals at the expense of the owner or person in custody thereof; and the company shall, in such case, have a lien upon such animals for food, care and custody furnished and shall not be liable for any detention of such animals.
SECTION 47-1-110. Violations of Sections 47-1-90 and 47-1-100.
Any company or the owner or custodian of such animals who shall fail to comply with the provisions of Sections 47-1-90 and 47-1-100 shall, for each and every such offense, if found guilty, be fined not less than fifty nor more than five hundred dollars, in any court of competent jurisdiction.
SECTION 47-1-120. Custody of animals in charge of arrested persons.
When a person arrested is, at the time of the arrest, in charge of an animal, an agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, may take charge of the animal and deposit the animal in a safe place of custody or deliver the animal into the possession of the police or sheriff of the county or place where the arrest was made, who shall assume the custody of the animal; and all necessary expenses incurred in taking charge of the animal shall be a lien thereon.
SECTION 47-1-125. Coloring or dying animals prohibited; sale or distribution of certain young animals prohibited; penalty.
(1) It is unlawful for any person to dye or color artificially any animal or fowl, including but not limited to rabbits, baby chickens, and ducklings, or to bring any dyed or colored animal or fowl into this State.
(2) It is unlawful for any person to sell, offer for sale or give away as merchandising premiums, baby chickens, ducklings or other fowl under four weeks of age or rabbits under two months of age to be used as pets, toys or retail premiums.
(3) This section shall not be construed to apply to any animal or fowl, including but not limited to rabbits, baby chickens and ducklings to be used or raised for agricultural purposes by persons with proper facilities to care for them or for poultry or livestock exhibitions.
(4) Any person violating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction shall be fined not more than two hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days.
SECTION 47-1-130. Arrest for violation of laws prohibiting cruelty to animals.
Any person violating the laws in relation to cruelty to animals may be arrested and held, without warrant, in the same manner as in the case of persons found breaking the peace.
SECTION 47-1-140. Care of animals after arrest of person in charge.
The person making the arrest, with or without warrant, shall use reasonable diligence to give notice to the owner of the animals found in the charge or custody of the person arrested, if the person is not the owner, and shall care and provide properly for the animals. The person making such arrest shall have a lien on the animals for the expense of such care and provision. But if such person making the arrest be an agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or other society incorporated for that purpose, the provisions of Section 47-1-120 shall apply in lieu of the provisions of this section. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, an animal may be seized preceding an arrest and pursuant to Section 47-1-150.
SECTION 47-1-150. Issuance of search warrant; purpose of section; motions regarding custody of animal; notice; care, disposal of, or return of animal.
(A) When complaint is made on oath or affirmation to any magistrate authorized to issue warrants in criminal cases that the complainant believes and has reasonable cause to believe that the laws in relation to cruelty to animals have been or are being violated in any particular building or place, such magistrate, if satisfied that there is reasonable cause for such belief, shall issue a search warrant authorizing any sheriff, deputy sheriff, deputy state constable, constable or police officer to search such building or place; but no search shall be made after sunset, unless specially authorized by the magistrate upon satisfactory cause shown. If an animal is seized pursuant to this section and the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty of Animals, or other society incorporated for that purpose is involved with the seizure, the animal may be held pending criminal disposition of the case at a facility maintained or contracted by that agency.
(B) The purpose of this section is to provide a means by which a neglected or mistreated animal can be:
(1) removed from its present custody, or
(2) made the subject of an order to provide care, issued to its owner by the magistrate or municipal judge, any law enforcement officer, or any agent of the county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or any society incorporated for that purpose and given protection and an appropriate and humane disposition made.
(C) Any law enforcement officer or any agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or any society incorporated for that purpose may move before a magistrate for an order to:
(1) lawfully take custody of any animal found neglected or cruelly treated by removing the animal from its present location if deemed by the court that removal is necessary to prevent further suffering or ill-treatment, or
(2) order the owner of any animal found neglected or cruelly treated to provide certain care to the animal at the owner's expense without removal of the animal from its present location, and shall forthwith petition the magistrate or municipal judge of the county or municipality wherein the animal is found for a hearing, to be set within twenty-four hours after the date of seizure of the animal or issuance of the order to provide care and held not more than two days after the setting of such date, to determine whether the owner, if known, is able to provide adequately for the animal and is fit to have custody of the animal. The hearing shall be concluded, and the court order entered the date the hearing is commenced. No fee shall be charged for the filing of the petition. Nothing herein is intended to require court action for the taking into custody and making proper disposition of stray or abandoned animals as lawfully performed by animal control agents.
(D) The officer or agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, taking charge of any animal pursuant to the provisions of this section shall have written notice served prior to the hearing set forth in subsection (C)(2), upon the owner of the animal, if he is known and is residing in the county where the animal was taken. The sheriff of the county shall not charge a fee for service of such notice. If the owner of the animal is known but is residing outside of the county wherein the animal was taken, notice of the hearing shall be by publication.
(E) If any seized animal held by court order at the owner's premises is removed without notification to the investigating agency, or if an animal becomes sick or dies, and the owner or custodian fails to immediately notify the investigating agency, the owner must be held in contempt of court and fined up to the penalties provided by law.
(F) The officer or agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, taking charge of an animal as provided for in this section shall provide for the animal until either:
(1) The owner is adjudged by the court to be able to provide adequately for, and have custody of, the animal, in which case the animal shall be returned to the owner upon payment for the care and provision of the animal while in the agent's or officer's custody; or
(2) The animal is turned over to the officer or agent as provided in Section 47-1-170 and a humane disposition of the animal is made.
(G) If the court determines that the owner is able to provide adequately for, and have custody of the animal, the order shall provide that the animal in possession of the officer or agent be claimed and removed by the owner within seven days after the date of the order.
SECTION 47-1-160. Disposition of fines.
All fines collected for violations of this chapter must be distributed as follows:
(1) If the trial court finds that there was a nonprofit animal humane organization in the municipality or county materially involved in or aiding in the prosecution of the violation, one-half of the fine must be distributed to the nonprofit animal humane organization and the remaining one-half must be distributed as is otherwise provided by law.
(2) If there is no finding of material involvement or aiding in the prosecution of the violation by a nonprofit animal humane organization, the fine must be distributed as is provided by law.
SECTION 47-1-170. Penalties for violations of chapter.
The owner or person having charge or custody of an animal cruelly used who is convicted of any violation of this chapter forfeits ownership, charge, or custody of the animal and at the discretion of the court, the person who is charged with or convicted of a violation of this chapter must be ordered to pay costs incurred to care for the animal and related expenses.
SECTION 47-1-200. Requirements for transfer of animals and importation or exportation of dog or cat; penalties for violations.
(A) During transportation, an animal must not be confined in one area for more than twenty-four consecutive hours without being adequately exercised, rested, fed, and watered. The time may be extended reasonably when an act of God causes a delay. The animal must be provided adequate space and ventilation.
(B) A dog or cat under eight weeks of age must not be imported or exported without being accompanied by its dam.
(C) A person who violates the provisions of this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be fined not less than two hundred nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days, or both.
SECTION 47-1-210. Live animals as prizes; exceptions; penalties.
(A) It is unlawful to give away a live animal including, but not limited to, a fish, bird, fowl, or reptile, as a prize for, or as an inducement to enter, any contest, game, or other competition, or as an inducement to enter a place of amusement, or for these species to be used as an incentive to enter into any business agreement if the offer made was for the purpose of attracting trade.
(B) Nothing in this section may be construed to prohibit an auction or raffle of a live animal including, but not limited to, a fish, bird, fowl, or reptile. Further, the giving away or the testing of game or fowl for breeding purposes only is lawful and is not prohibited by this section as an incentive to enter into a business agreement if the person giving away or testing game or fowl is engaged in that trade.
(C) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished for each separate offense by a fine not to exceed three hundred dollars or imprisonment not to exceed thirty days, or both.
(D) This section does not apply when a live animal is given away as follows:
(1) by individuals or organizations operating in conjunction with a cooperative extension education program or agricultural vocational program sanctioned by the State Department of Education or local school districts;
(2) by individuals or organizations operating in conjunction with field trials approved by the Department of Natural Resources; or
(3) by kennels that advertise in national publications in regard to dogs that are registered with the United Kennel Club or the American Kennel Club.
Regulating the treatment of animals is not a modern concept. It’s in the bible. That’s pretty old. Lot of primitive cultures had certain ways of telling their people what was allowed and what was not. For example, the bible says in what manner animals for food may be killed. I am talking Old Testament here. Part of Kosher is a clean, humane slaughter. First argument; but that was religion and not a law. Wrong, religious beliefs were the law back then. You violate a religious practice and you might get stoned to death. There was no separation of church and state in a really big way. Old Testament does not wait for you to go to hell. They punish you themselves.
However, even back in biblical times the treatment of animals was a hodgepodge of completely random and capricious rules. Some eastern cultures forbid the intentional killing of any living thing—even an insect. Not so in our Judeo-Christian belief system. Kill the steer cleanly with no suffering, stay away from the pigs, fish have no rules unless they have a shell and if its vermin you kill it as fast as you can by any means. That is not a logical system. And its purpose is unclear. I am going to stick to the Judeo-Christian belief system because that is what out modern moral and legal code is derived from. At least for now.
In between biblical times and modern times the role and treatment of animals has mostly been all over the place. Prohibitions on treating animals poorly may have been for economic reasons, moral reasons, or just plain pride in a job well done. At times animals had no protections from ill abuse, but were subject to criminal prosecutions for moral failings. In the Middle Ages and right past the renaissance animals could be and were tried for crimes. If a human was tried for bestiality the animal was right there next to him and tried too. Dogs, cats, rats and all other creatures, even bugs, had court appointed lawyers to make sure they were guilty before they were executed for their crimes. For a long period of time an animal was entitled to much better legal representation than a human. I am just recounting theses facts. I am not even going to begin to try and explain it. Let’s just say morality was so important back then that even a rat had to act according to human social norms. And The Rule of Law was new and sort of cool so maybe they just got carried away.
The basis of our American modern anti-cruelty statutes is about 150 years old. It was considered bad for the morals of women and children to have to see animals beaten to death in the streets of the cities, so the first modern laws were drafted. The laws were not to protect animals, but to protect humans from having to witness such gruesome scenes. The constitutional basis for state police action was to protect the moral good—an allowed use of state powers. Over the years it was to protect moral good and human health and safety. But the key is that it was all about us and not about them. Then, due to changes in the political system, our nation laws started getting written that protected animals from cruelty for the animal’s sake.
Groups of concerned citizens could lobby for laws to be changed. People now had pets and saw some animals in a different light. Women got the vote and they became actively involved in “safe, feminine” causes like animal welfare acts. So on that day when the first anti-cruelty statute was written and put into a code section just for animals like the SC one below, animals had rights.
Commence freaking out now. I mean, we all know that Animal Rights is a future thing that we either support or fear, but most of us are completely blind to the fact AR are not new and are already in place. Isn’t that what PETA and the HSUS want? Certainly I am not lumping supporters of animal welfare among those that support animal rights! Yes, I am. A “right” is something granted by force of law and if there are laws granting certain animals the right to have minimum basic needs met, they have a RIGHT to those needs. They have a right to welfare standards set out by law. They have people assigned that can ask a court to enforce that right. They have rights already, so let that sink in.
Now, which animals have rights and what rights they have is controlled by both state and federal law. There are a lot of laws out there. The easiest way to get a handle on understanding what we are dealing with is to break it up into 2 kinds of crimes—neglect and cruelty. Neglect can be just ignorance or less then ideal conditions while cruelty is usually, but not always, intentional and outrageous. They often carry more severe punishments for intentional cruelty and there is less disagreement in what constitutes cruelty then neglect. Less, but not none.
The laws themselves often create completely artificial divisions between animals. They are based on which animals we have emotional feelings for and which ones we do not care for. They also exclude lots of common farming practices because while we may be outraged at a starving puppy, we do not want that to interfere with out hamburger for dinner. And fur and 4 legs ranks higher in most cases then other life forms, unless they are vermin and then we apply a completely different standard. If they are wild and endangered yet another standard is applied.
There is absolutely no rhyme or reason behind these laws if the object is to protect animals from unnecessary suffering. They reflect a world view of a Disney animation team as much as they do any logical distinctions. So, in many ways they are just like a lot of other laws. Its illegal because we say so, now go eat your pudding. We make it up and then justify it later. As long as most of us agree, it’s all fine and dandy. Because fish can’t feel pain anyway, right? No, not really. I eat raw oysters. That means I eat them ALIVE and they die when they hit my stomach acid. I am pretty sure if I quaffed down a few live kittens I would not be invited to your next dinner party.
So besides the fact that everything we think we know is probably wrong, it may also be unconstitutional to give animals rights without amending the constitution in some way. I know that is pretty far out there, but people go to jail for violating the rights of a non-human animal. But only some animals and some activities are illegal with absolutely no real standard to apply and no real state interest to allow police action. Animals are not supposed to have rights. If they do then don’t all animals have them? It sort of seems like the definition of arbitrary and capricious to me and in many cases the application of these laws is as arbitrary as I can possibly imagine. For example, say you have a pet pig and someone claims you are neglecting it. Just walk outside, shoot it with arrows until its good and dead and eat it. Problem solved. No pig no rights no case. And bacon is yummy. Huh? Or your horses are fine but the rats on our farm and in poor shape. Didn’t the statute say ALL non human animals? But what do they really mean? Is it vague? Like too vague? Like maybe void for vagueness vague?
Here is the SC code. Read it. Really read it. Who is it designed to protect? Who is it designed to punish? Can you see the difference between neglect and cruelty? Can you actually apply this law or see a way to comply with it?
Title 47 - Animals, Livestock and Poultry
CHAPTER 1.
CRUELTY TO ANIMALS
SECTION 47-1-10. Definitions.
As used in this chapter:
(1) "Animal" means a living vertebrate creature except a homo sapien.
(2) "Sustenance" means adequate food provided at suitable intervals of quantities of wholesome foodstuff suitable for the species and age, sufficient to maintain a reasonable level of nutrition to allow for proper growth and weight and adequate water provided with constant access to a supply of clean, fresh, and potable water provided in a suitable manner for the species.
(3) "Shelter" means shelter that reasonably may be expected to protect the animal from physical suffering or impairment of health due to exposure to the elements or adverse weather.
SECTION 47-1-20. Acts of agents imputed to corporations.
The knowledge and acts of agents and persons employed by corporations in regard to animals transported, owned or employed by or in the custody of such corporations shall be held to be the acts and knowledge of such corporations.
SECTION 47-1-30. Repealed by 1998 Act No. 367, Section 9, eff May 27, 1998.
SECTION 47-1-40. Ill-treatment of animals generally.
(A) Whoever knowingly or intentionally overloads, overdrives, overworks, ill-treats any animal, deprives any animal of necessary sustenance or shelter, inflicts unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal, or by omission or commission knowingly or intentionally causes these things to be done, for every offense is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment not exceeding sixty days or by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars nor more than five hundred dollars, or both, for a first offense; by imprisonment not exceeding ninety days or by a fine not exceeding eight hundred dollars, or both, for a second offense; or by imprisonment not exceeding two years or by a fine not exceeding two thousand dollars, or both, for a third or subsequent offense. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a first offense under this subsection shall be tried in magistrate's or municipal court.
(B) Whoever tortures, torments, needlessly mutilates, cruelly kills, or inflicts excessive or repeated unnecessary pain or suffering upon any animal or by omission or commission causes the acts to be done for any of the offenses is guilty of a felony and, upon conviction, must be punished by imprisonment of not less than one hundred eighty days and not to exceed five years and by a fine of five thousand dollars.
(C) This section does not apply to fowl, accepted animal husbandry practices of farm operations and the training of animals, the practice of veterinary medicine, agricultural practices, forestry and silvacultural practices, wildlife management practices, or activity authorized by Title 50, including an activity authorized by the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources or an exercise designed for training dogs for hunting, if repeated contact with a dog or dogs and another animal does not occur during this training exercise.
SECTION 47-1-50. Cruel work; carriage in vehicles; penalties.
(A) An owner, a possessor, or a person having the charge or custody of an animal may not:
(1) cruelly drive or work it when unfit for labor;
(2) carry it, or cause it to be carried, in or upon a vehicle or otherwise in an unnecessarily cruel or inhumane manner.
(B) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished for each offense in the manner prescribed in Section 47-1-40(A).
SECTION 47-1-60. Cutting muscles of tails of horses, asses, mules, mares, or geldings prohibited.
Any person who (a) cuts the tissue or muscle of the tail of any horse, ass, mule, mare or gelding, or otherwise operates upon it in any manner for the purpose or with the effect of altering the natural carriage of the tail, except when such cutting or operation is necessary for the health or life of the animal, as certified to in writing by a licensed veterinarian, (b) causes, procures or knowingly permits such cutting or operation to be done or (c) assists in or is voluntarily present at such cutting or operation shall be guilty of a misdemeanor.
Any person convicted of violating any of the provisions of this section shall be fined not less than fifty nor more than one hundred dollars or imprisoned not less than fifteen nor more than thirty days.
SECTION 47-1-70. Abandonment of animals; penalties; hunting dog exception.
(A) A person may not abandon an animal. As used in this section "abandonment" is defined as deserting, forsaking, or intending to give up absolutely an animal without securing another owner or without providing the necessities of life. "Necessities of life" includes:
(1) adequate water which means a constant access to a supply of clean, fresh, and potable water provided in a suitable manner for the species;
(2) adequate food which means provision at suitable intervals of quantities of wholesome foodstuff suitable for the species and age, sufficient to maintain a reasonable level of nutrition to allow for proper growth and weight;
(3) adequate shelter which means shelter that reasonably may be expected to protect the animal from physical suffering or impairment of health due to exposure to the elements or adverse weather.
(B) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be fined not less than two hundred nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned not more than thirty days, or both. Offenses under this section must be tried in the magistrate's or municipal court.
(C) A hunting dog that is positively identifiable in accordance with Section 47-3-510 or Section 47-3-530 is exempt from this section.
SECTION 47-1-75. Immunity from civil and criminal liability.
Any person, including a person licensed to practice veterinary medicine, or an animal control officer or agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or any society incorporated for that purpose, who in good faith and without compensation for services provided, acting without malice, recklessness, or gross negligence, renders emergency care or treatment to a domestic animal which is abandoned, ill, injured, or in distress related to an accident or disaster shall not be liable or subject to any civil or criminal liability for any injuries or harm to such animal resulting from the rendering of such care or treatment, or any act or failure to act to provide or arrange for further medical treatment or care for such animal.
SECTION 47-1-80. Destruction of abandoned infirm animal.
Any agent or officer of the Department of Health and Environmental Control or police officer or officer of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals or of any society duly incorporated for that purpose may lawfully destroy, or cause to be destroyed, any animal found abandoned and not properly cared for, appearing to be glandered, injured or diseased past recovery for any useful purpose.
SECTION 47-1-90. Overloading and length of confinement of animals in railroad cars.
No railroad company in the carrying or transportation of animals shall overload the cars nor permit the animals to be confined in cars for a longer period than thirty-six consecutive hours without unloading them for rest, water and feeding for a period of at least five consecutive hours, unless prevented from so unloading by storm or other accidental causes beyond the control of such railroad company; provided, however, that when animals shall be carried in cars in which they can and do have proper food, water and space and opportunity for rest, the foregoing provisions in regard to their being unloaded shall not apply.
In estimating such confinement the time during which the animals have been confined without such rest on connecting roads from which they are received shall be included, it being the intent of this section to prohibit their continuous confinement beyond the period of thirty-six hours, except upon the contingencies hereinbefore stated.
SECTION 47-1-100. Care of animals unloaded during transit.
Animals unloaded as required by Section 47-1-90 shall be properly fed, watered and sheltered during such rest by the owner or person having the custody thereof or, in case of his default in so doing, then by the railroad company transporting such animals at the expense of the owner or person in custody thereof; and the company shall, in such case, have a lien upon such animals for food, care and custody furnished and shall not be liable for any detention of such animals.
SECTION 47-1-110. Violations of Sections 47-1-90 and 47-1-100.
Any company or the owner or custodian of such animals who shall fail to comply with the provisions of Sections 47-1-90 and 47-1-100 shall, for each and every such offense, if found guilty, be fined not less than fifty nor more than five hundred dollars, in any court of competent jurisdiction.
SECTION 47-1-120. Custody of animals in charge of arrested persons.
When a person arrested is, at the time of the arrest, in charge of an animal, an agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, may take charge of the animal and deposit the animal in a safe place of custody or deliver the animal into the possession of the police or sheriff of the county or place where the arrest was made, who shall assume the custody of the animal; and all necessary expenses incurred in taking charge of the animal shall be a lien thereon.
SECTION 47-1-125. Coloring or dying animals prohibited; sale or distribution of certain young animals prohibited; penalty.
(1) It is unlawful for any person to dye or color artificially any animal or fowl, including but not limited to rabbits, baby chickens, and ducklings, or to bring any dyed or colored animal or fowl into this State.
(2) It is unlawful for any person to sell, offer for sale or give away as merchandising premiums, baby chickens, ducklings or other fowl under four weeks of age or rabbits under two months of age to be used as pets, toys or retail premiums.
(3) This section shall not be construed to apply to any animal or fowl, including but not limited to rabbits, baby chickens and ducklings to be used or raised for agricultural purposes by persons with proper facilities to care for them or for poultry or livestock exhibitions.
(4) Any person violating the provisions of this section shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and upon conviction shall be fined not more than two hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days.
SECTION 47-1-130. Arrest for violation of laws prohibiting cruelty to animals.
Any person violating the laws in relation to cruelty to animals may be arrested and held, without warrant, in the same manner as in the case of persons found breaking the peace.
SECTION 47-1-140. Care of animals after arrest of person in charge.
The person making the arrest, with or without warrant, shall use reasonable diligence to give notice to the owner of the animals found in the charge or custody of the person arrested, if the person is not the owner, and shall care and provide properly for the animals. The person making such arrest shall have a lien on the animals for the expense of such care and provision. But if such person making the arrest be an agent of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or other society incorporated for that purpose, the provisions of Section 47-1-120 shall apply in lieu of the provisions of this section. Notwithstanding any other provision of law, an animal may be seized preceding an arrest and pursuant to Section 47-1-150.
SECTION 47-1-150. Issuance of search warrant; purpose of section; motions regarding custody of animal; notice; care, disposal of, or return of animal.
(A) When complaint is made on oath or affirmation to any magistrate authorized to issue warrants in criminal cases that the complainant believes and has reasonable cause to believe that the laws in relation to cruelty to animals have been or are being violated in any particular building or place, such magistrate, if satisfied that there is reasonable cause for such belief, shall issue a search warrant authorizing any sheriff, deputy sheriff, deputy state constable, constable or police officer to search such building or place; but no search shall be made after sunset, unless specially authorized by the magistrate upon satisfactory cause shown. If an animal is seized pursuant to this section and the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty of Animals, or other society incorporated for that purpose is involved with the seizure, the animal may be held pending criminal disposition of the case at a facility maintained or contracted by that agency.
(B) The purpose of this section is to provide a means by which a neglected or mistreated animal can be:
(1) removed from its present custody, or
(2) made the subject of an order to provide care, issued to its owner by the magistrate or municipal judge, any law enforcement officer, or any agent of the county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or any society incorporated for that purpose and given protection and an appropriate and humane disposition made.
(C) Any law enforcement officer or any agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or any society incorporated for that purpose may move before a magistrate for an order to:
(1) lawfully take custody of any animal found neglected or cruelly treated by removing the animal from its present location if deemed by the court that removal is necessary to prevent further suffering or ill-treatment, or
(2) order the owner of any animal found neglected or cruelly treated to provide certain care to the animal at the owner's expense without removal of the animal from its present location, and shall forthwith petition the magistrate or municipal judge of the county or municipality wherein the animal is found for a hearing, to be set within twenty-four hours after the date of seizure of the animal or issuance of the order to provide care and held not more than two days after the setting of such date, to determine whether the owner, if known, is able to provide adequately for the animal and is fit to have custody of the animal. The hearing shall be concluded, and the court order entered the date the hearing is commenced. No fee shall be charged for the filing of the petition. Nothing herein is intended to require court action for the taking into custody and making proper disposition of stray or abandoned animals as lawfully performed by animal control agents.
(D) The officer or agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, taking charge of any animal pursuant to the provisions of this section shall have written notice served prior to the hearing set forth in subsection (C)(2), upon the owner of the animal, if he is known and is residing in the county where the animal was taken. The sheriff of the county shall not charge a fee for service of such notice. If the owner of the animal is known but is residing outside of the county wherein the animal was taken, notice of the hearing shall be by publication.
(E) If any seized animal held by court order at the owner's premises is removed without notification to the investigating agency, or if an animal becomes sick or dies, and the owner or custodian fails to immediately notify the investigating agency, the owner must be held in contempt of court and fined up to the penalties provided by law.
(F) The officer or agent of any county or of the South Carolina Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, or of any society incorporated for that purpose, taking charge of an animal as provided for in this section shall provide for the animal until either:
(1) The owner is adjudged by the court to be able to provide adequately for, and have custody of, the animal, in which case the animal shall be returned to the owner upon payment for the care and provision of the animal while in the agent's or officer's custody; or
(2) The animal is turned over to the officer or agent as provided in Section 47-1-170 and a humane disposition of the animal is made.
(G) If the court determines that the owner is able to provide adequately for, and have custody of the animal, the order shall provide that the animal in possession of the officer or agent be claimed and removed by the owner within seven days after the date of the order.
SECTION 47-1-160. Disposition of fines.
All fines collected for violations of this chapter must be distributed as follows:
(1) If the trial court finds that there was a nonprofit animal humane organization in the municipality or county materially involved in or aiding in the prosecution of the violation, one-half of the fine must be distributed to the nonprofit animal humane organization and the remaining one-half must be distributed as is otherwise provided by law.
(2) If there is no finding of material involvement or aiding in the prosecution of the violation by a nonprofit animal humane organization, the fine must be distributed as is provided by law.
SECTION 47-1-170. Penalties for violations of chapter.
The owner or person having charge or custody of an animal cruelly used who is convicted of any violation of this chapter forfeits ownership, charge, or custody of the animal and at the discretion of the court, the person who is charged with or convicted of a violation of this chapter must be ordered to pay costs incurred to care for the animal and related expenses.
SECTION 47-1-200. Requirements for transfer of animals and importation or exportation of dog or cat; penalties for violations.
(A) During transportation, an animal must not be confined in one area for more than twenty-four consecutive hours without being adequately exercised, rested, fed, and watered. The time may be extended reasonably when an act of God causes a delay. The animal must be provided adequate space and ventilation.
(B) A dog or cat under eight weeks of age must not be imported or exported without being accompanied by its dam.
(C) A person who violates the provisions of this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be fined not less than two hundred nor more than five hundred dollars or imprisoned for not more than thirty days, or both.
SECTION 47-1-210. Live animals as prizes; exceptions; penalties.
(A) It is unlawful to give away a live animal including, but not limited to, a fish, bird, fowl, or reptile, as a prize for, or as an inducement to enter, any contest, game, or other competition, or as an inducement to enter a place of amusement, or for these species to be used as an incentive to enter into any business agreement if the offer made was for the purpose of attracting trade.
(B) Nothing in this section may be construed to prohibit an auction or raffle of a live animal including, but not limited to, a fish, bird, fowl, or reptile. Further, the giving away or the testing of game or fowl for breeding purposes only is lawful and is not prohibited by this section as an incentive to enter into a business agreement if the person giving away or testing game or fowl is engaged in that trade.
(C) A person who violates this section is guilty of a misdemeanor and, upon conviction, must be punished for each separate offense by a fine not to exceed three hundred dollars or imprisonment not to exceed thirty days, or both.
(D) This section does not apply when a live animal is given away as follows:
(1) by individuals or organizations operating in conjunction with a cooperative extension education program or agricultural vocational program sanctioned by the State Department of Education or local school districts;
(2) by individuals or organizations operating in conjunction with field trials approved by the Department of Natural Resources; or
(3) by kennels that advertise in national publications in regard to dogs that are registered with the United Kennel Club or the American Kennel Club.
Wednesday, February 18, 2009
Animal Welfare Laws: Abuse and Neglect part I
Ahhhhhh. Finally. Some time to blog. A squall line just passed through tranquil Aiken, SC, shutting down the power for miles around. I know it’s a “squall line” because I was watching actual LIVE TV right before the power went off. The news was saying the “squall line had passed”. The weather was not watching the news, or if it was, it was not going to bow to the puny power of the local news guy and either turned around and came back just for spite or hung around because Aiken is so lovely. This does explain why my Dad sent me a cryptic e-mail at 2 pm saying if I need to go to a hotel to avoid tornadoes, charge it to his credit card. Although last time a hurricane hit my house I did not see it coming and would not have been in a hotel. But it was sweet to offer anyway.
Either way, the TV and lights all went out and the house got silent. Except for 3 things: 1) the panting of the damn dog who is thunder and rain phobic, 2) the soft sounds of The Boxer from Hell continually passing rancid gas and 3) the comforting glow of my lap-top. Because, baby, laptops have batteries and I still have a computer!!! Granted, I am cut off from my hard won AT&T wireless DSL which promised to be faithful through thick and thin yet bounced at the first sign of a power failure, but at least I have some light and can get some work done because heaven forbid I just sit quietly or go to sleep with the damn dog still panting and trying to crawl over the crate of the methane powered Boxer from Hell. And since I have no idea how long laptop batteries last and can’t find my flashlight anywhere, I’d better get to the subject at hand. Or lap. Or whatever.
Animal Abuse and Neglect. Animal abuse and neglect cases are tricky. Cruelty cases are often much easier, because most of us can agree on what is cruel, but unfortunately, like most laws, the codes of many states on animal welfare seem to have been written on a laptop while the power was out and leave too much to the discretions of law enforcement officers. I will eventually insert some examples of state laws (here) but that will have to wait until I have actual internet access.
First, let me say that in the last 10-20 years we have come light-years toward better legal protections for animals. When I was young, there wasn’t much in the way of animal cruelty law enforcement at all. When I was younger, but not as young, cruelty laws were starting to be enforced, but neglect cases were unheard of. We did not have “animal hoarders” and “seizures”. We had the Krazy Kat Lady down the road and most enforcement was done under the human health codes and not separate animal welfare codes. The power just came back on. Thank you Aiken Electric Co-op and you poor men and women out there in the rain making sure my 4 loyal readers have something to see in the next few days!
In the olden days, when Krazy Kat lady down the street had 450 cats in her 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch house they were taken under the auspices of the health department or a local code limiting the number of house pets one may have. The focus was on protecting human health and welfare. It was not on saving the cats. Now we have animal welfare codes. Well we may have always had them, but they were never enforced, and the focus is on saving the animals—not the humans. But more importantly, the old codes were civil and only quasi-criminal in nature. The new codes are criminal. Criminal prosecutions bring in all those bothersome protections of the Constitution. Old fashioned administrative actions do not. So in order to save animals, you have to protect the constitutional rights of the animal owners. This makes things harder and makes people very passionate and emotional and upset about who will have the power to enforce and how the power will be used. KKL got herself a posse. Or a lynch mob. It depends on whether the TV and internet are working, I guess.
And the power just went on, so I’ll post this and see what happens:>
Either way, the TV and lights all went out and the house got silent. Except for 3 things: 1) the panting of the damn dog who is thunder and rain phobic, 2) the soft sounds of The Boxer from Hell continually passing rancid gas and 3) the comforting glow of my lap-top. Because, baby, laptops have batteries and I still have a computer!!! Granted, I am cut off from my hard won AT&T wireless DSL which promised to be faithful through thick and thin yet bounced at the first sign of a power failure, but at least I have some light and can get some work done because heaven forbid I just sit quietly or go to sleep with the damn dog still panting and trying to crawl over the crate of the methane powered Boxer from Hell. And since I have no idea how long laptop batteries last and can’t find my flashlight anywhere, I’d better get to the subject at hand. Or lap. Or whatever.
Animal Abuse and Neglect. Animal abuse and neglect cases are tricky. Cruelty cases are often much easier, because most of us can agree on what is cruel, but unfortunately, like most laws, the codes of many states on animal welfare seem to have been written on a laptop while the power was out and leave too much to the discretions of law enforcement officers. I will eventually insert some examples of state laws (here) but that will have to wait until I have actual internet access.
First, let me say that in the last 10-20 years we have come light-years toward better legal protections for animals. When I was young, there wasn’t much in the way of animal cruelty law enforcement at all. When I was younger, but not as young, cruelty laws were starting to be enforced, but neglect cases were unheard of. We did not have “animal hoarders” and “seizures”. We had the Krazy Kat Lady down the road and most enforcement was done under the human health codes and not separate animal welfare codes. The power just came back on. Thank you Aiken Electric Co-op and you poor men and women out there in the rain making sure my 4 loyal readers have something to see in the next few days!
In the olden days, when Krazy Kat lady down the street had 450 cats in her 3 bedroom, 2 bath ranch house they were taken under the auspices of the health department or a local code limiting the number of house pets one may have. The focus was on protecting human health and welfare. It was not on saving the cats. Now we have animal welfare codes. Well we may have always had them, but they were never enforced, and the focus is on saving the animals—not the humans. But more importantly, the old codes were civil and only quasi-criminal in nature. The new codes are criminal. Criminal prosecutions bring in all those bothersome protections of the Constitution. Old fashioned administrative actions do not. So in order to save animals, you have to protect the constitutional rights of the animal owners. This makes things harder and makes people very passionate and emotional and upset about who will have the power to enforce and how the power will be used. KKL got herself a posse. Or a lynch mob. It depends on whether the TV and internet are working, I guess.
And the power just went on, so I’ll post this and see what happens:>
Monday, February 16, 2009
Re-cap of what has already been posted.
In the past I have posted about estate planning for animal owners, liability for horse owners and barn owners, proposed legislation to clean up the horse industry, loose livestock, dog law, contracts including leases and waivers and a few other subjects. Click on the archives and open up the indexes.
And remember, I do law, others do tech. There are many web addresses that are not live links. Just cut and paste them into your browser.
This blog is designed to build on previous posts. If you read the section on contracts then cases with contracts in them will be clear. Same with other topics. When I post new stuff you may have to go back and read old stuff to fully understand what I am talking about. Because this blog is for non-lawyers and its is meant to make you readers educated consumers of legal services and help you prevent problems--not solve them once its too late.
As much as I love $$$$$ I would rather be helping people prevent lawsuits by understanding their rights and obligations then making money cleaning up messes that could have been avoided. A little bit of knowledge is a dangerous thing, but its also a good place to start to gain more knowledge.
You can ask 10 different lawyers the same question and get 10 different answers. We have reached a point in which The Law is no longer a big mystery hidden from clients behind a veil of dusty libraries and Latin terms. You can and must think for yourself. Listen to your lawyer, pay your lawyer, but take the time to educate yourself so if you find you are in need of a lawyer you can tell which one you need and not pay $$$$$$$$$$$$ to have concepts explained to you that you can learn yourself. Don't try and be your own lawyer, but you can reduce the stress of a legal action by having some idea of what is going on.
The answer may be that the law dates back to the 15th century and the needs of a King. No way you are going to guess that on your own, but understanding why things are as they are can do a whole lot to lower your blood pressure and demystify that stack of meaningless papers with terms like demurrer and laches and duty and breach.
And please, whenever possible, PREVENT messes instead of paying to clean them up!
Now back to just posting what I hope is a mix of educational material and somewhat amusing examples and cometary.
And remember, I do law, others do tech. There are many web addresses that are not live links. Just cut and paste them into your browser.
This blog is designed to build on previous posts. If you read the section on contracts then cases with contracts in them will be clear. Same with other topics. When I post new stuff you may have to go back and read old stuff to fully understand what I am talking about. Because this blog is for non-lawyers and its is meant to make you readers educated consumers of legal services and help you prevent problems--not solve them once its too late.
As much as I love $$$$$ I would rather be helping people prevent lawsuits by understanding their rights and obligations then making money cleaning up messes that could have been avoided. A little bit of knowledge is a dangerous thing, but its also a good place to start to gain more knowledge.
You can ask 10 different lawyers the same question and get 10 different answers. We have reached a point in which The Law is no longer a big mystery hidden from clients behind a veil of dusty libraries and Latin terms. You can and must think for yourself. Listen to your lawyer, pay your lawyer, but take the time to educate yourself so if you find you are in need of a lawyer you can tell which one you need and not pay $$$$$$$$$$$$ to have concepts explained to you that you can learn yourself. Don't try and be your own lawyer, but you can reduce the stress of a legal action by having some idea of what is going on.
The answer may be that the law dates back to the 15th century and the needs of a King. No way you are going to guess that on your own, but understanding why things are as they are can do a whole lot to lower your blood pressure and demystify that stack of meaningless papers with terms like demurrer and laches and duty and breach.
And please, whenever possible, PREVENT messes instead of paying to clean them up!
Now back to just posting what I hope is a mix of educational material and somewhat amusing examples and cometary.
I am Still Here! Just Behind in Posting.
So here are the topics I will be posting soon.
1) Animal abuse and neglect--the good, the bad and the ugly.
2) Liability for the Animals in your Care--you have duties to the animals too.
3) Taxes and why I hate tax time--Hobby vs Business and why you already know the answer
4) Employee or Contractor?--Should you be paying taxes and workers comp on that barn help?
I will answer 1 question from a SC resident. It will not be legal advice. I will not tell you what you should do. I will explain what is happening and why and what SC law says on the subject. Your mileage may vary.
Then I will start posting results of real cases. Now that you readers have had a mini version of a first year law school education, you should be able to have thoughts and opinions on the thoughts and opinions of what judges around the country have decided. There are no right answers, but the guy in the robe wins.
Its time to introduce the readers to the real world results.
1) Animal abuse and neglect--the good, the bad and the ugly.
2) Liability for the Animals in your Care--you have duties to the animals too.
3) Taxes and why I hate tax time--Hobby vs Business and why you already know the answer
4) Employee or Contractor?--Should you be paying taxes and workers comp on that barn help?
I will answer 1 question from a SC resident. It will not be legal advice. I will not tell you what you should do. I will explain what is happening and why and what SC law says on the subject. Your mileage may vary.
Then I will start posting results of real cases. Now that you readers have had a mini version of a first year law school education, you should be able to have thoughts and opinions on the thoughts and opinions of what judges around the country have decided. There are no right answers, but the guy in the robe wins.
Its time to introduce the readers to the real world results.
Saturday, January 31, 2009
You be the Judge (or Jury).
Example #1. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jM1Lp51HRjs
I have nothing against people riding horses with no tack. Remember, its not negligence to hurt yourself. I do think in a state with a negligence standard for loose horses, once you leave a safe enclosed environment and go out in the open you will have very hard time convincing a judge or jury your horse was under control if you get dumped and the horse gets away. Its just like a dog off a leash—you may feel your training gives you control, but its not enough.
Example #2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3SBl09gp1sA
Is this fence going to keep horses in?
Example #3 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCwY7rTRN5g
This fence is not keeping any horse in. And what do they do? They film it!
Example #4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bO5FgTY95ww
This one just has it all. The gate is broken. The owners are out of town. They have no horse sitter. They do not seem to know where the halters are. Somehow their clueless neighbors manage to save the day just by being really smart. They know nothing about horses, but they manage to get them back home safely.
Notice all the kids sitting around while horses gallop on the roads out of control. Notice in the end a woman says her horses are out all the time. The State Police call her to come and get them often.
Negligence?? It’s hard to say. That gate looks busted, but the place looks in very good shape. Maybe some kids came and took the halters and tried to play with the horses? In a strict liability state they would be at fault and look how many people could have been hurt! In a negligence state it may just be one of those things and there does not seem to be a history of these horses getting free.
I hope they bought those wonderful neighbors a new car or something!
Lastly, Example #5. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf83qDtIFpo
Yes, I know my jumper can clear 4 ft. But if I know he will not abide by our domestication agreement that he stay put in a reasonable fence, then I have to do something about it. That something is not make sure I capture it on film to post on the internet.
I have nothing against people riding horses with no tack. Remember, its not negligence to hurt yourself. I do think in a state with a negligence standard for loose horses, once you leave a safe enclosed environment and go out in the open you will have very hard time convincing a judge or jury your horse was under control if you get dumped and the horse gets away. Its just like a dog off a leash—you may feel your training gives you control, but its not enough.
Example #2 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3SBl09gp1sA
Is this fence going to keep horses in?
Example #3 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCwY7rTRN5g
This fence is not keeping any horse in. And what do they do? They film it!
Example #4 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bO5FgTY95ww
This one just has it all. The gate is broken. The owners are out of town. They have no horse sitter. They do not seem to know where the halters are. Somehow their clueless neighbors manage to save the day just by being really smart. They know nothing about horses, but they manage to get them back home safely.
Notice all the kids sitting around while horses gallop on the roads out of control. Notice in the end a woman says her horses are out all the time. The State Police call her to come and get them often.
Negligence?? It’s hard to say. That gate looks busted, but the place looks in very good shape. Maybe some kids came and took the halters and tried to play with the horses? In a strict liability state they would be at fault and look how many people could have been hurt! In a negligence state it may just be one of those things and there does not seem to be a history of these horses getting free.
I hope they bought those wonderful neighbors a new car or something!
Lastly, Example #5. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gf83qDtIFpo
Yes, I know my jumper can clear 4 ft. But if I know he will not abide by our domestication agreement that he stay put in a reasonable fence, then I have to do something about it. That something is not make sure I capture it on film to post on the internet.
Thursday, January 29, 2009
Loose Horses. Confusing and Complicated.
Ok. Now you have had some time to digest what a scary liability filled world you live in. You have updated our releases, looked around and lowered your liability exposure and finally feel safe and secure again. Time to get you all worried once more. What if an animal gets off your property and someone gets hurt?
Just like with liability in general, your liability and responsibilities will depend on your state. You have two sources of law: the state code and the case law that interprets what the state code means. For example, the state code may say "[a] person who owns or has responsibility for the control of a horse, mule, donkey, cow, bull, steer, hog, sheep, or goat may not knowingly permit the animal to traverse or roam at large, unattended, on the right-of-way of a highway. Now the courts must interpret “knowingly, highway, right of way and unattended. Each state will have a code and a big pile of case law to interpret that code. See “equinelaw.alisonrowe.com/2008/05/articles/livestock-laws/is-a-horseowner-liable-for-damages-if-a-horse-gets-loose” for an example of just how complicated this can be.
Some states have strict liability. That means if the animal is out and causes damages you pay. Nobody cares if you were at fault or negligent or knowingly did anything. You go straight from duty to damages with no stopping at breach or causation. Its out, you pay. Some states only hold you responsible for personal injuries if you negligently or knowingly let the animal get out. How they interpret “negligence” can range from “if its out you must have been negligent” (hence it becomes strict liability) to “you must have left a gate open or had ratty old fences or common practices that prove it’s your fault” or you win. Lastly, some states simply do not care. They put the burden on anyone out there to avoid loose livestock and fence it out or swerve around it if it’s on the road. You have no duty at all. They have a duty to not get hurt.
Why so much variation and interpretation about estrays? There are many reasons, but the biggest ones are that loose animals can cause serious damage and that often leads to insurance claims. Insurance companies can afford to fight legal battles as far as they can go. One loose horse can cause wrecked cars, dead people, permanent physical damage and extensive property damage. Someone has to pay and that is usually the insurance company. The other reason is simply the states historical traditions. Western states usually see livestock as having a right to everywhere they are not fenced out. Free range grazing is the norm so if you want a cow free yard or road you need to pay for the fence to keep them away. Eastern states are the opposite. You fence in or else. Depending on how often a code is updated adjoining counties may conflict so your farm may be half fence out and half fence in!
When you read case law you are usually reading the appeal of the original verdict. Most trial courts are not courts of record. You may read a short blurb or a news article about the case, but it is not until the appeal that legal opinions are rendered for publications by the courts. If its gotten as far as an appeal there is either a serious injury or an insurance company involved. A case like that would have taken several years and tens of thousands of dollars to reach an appellate decision. You do not see case law about Dobbin getting loose and eating neighbors Pansy patch. You see case law about horses on the road and smashed cars and broken bones or worse.
Often, the law is pretty clear on property damage from loose animals. You will pay for the Pansy patch or broken fence or ruined crops. When things get fuzzy and expensive is when some human or other animal gets injured. Vet bills and personal injury bills get expensive. The lawyers and insurance companies will try these cases and in some ways they make the judges make the laws. Whoever loses will almost certainly appeal. So you see lots of case law in this area.
So, how to find out the law in your state? First read the code. It’s usually under animals and or livestock. Then check your local county code. They may have something to say about animals too. Next, you will have to read the recent case law in your state. Sometimes it’s sort of surprising. For example, in Georgia they use a negligence standard, but the actual case law defines negligence in ways we might not. A horse got loose by breaking the gate and fence. The judge found that was negligence because the fence posts where not set in concrete. The horse had no history of breaking out or needing special fences, but the judge felt that if the posts had been set in concrete the horse would have not been able to escape. Kind of makes you wonder what a GA judge would think or electric wire fences?
You do not need to be a lawyer to look up case law and you do not need access to a law library or a subscription data base. Use google. Use the terms you are interested in like car+horse+injury but also use Plaintiff or Defendant or appellant and court. That will narrow down your results quite a bit. Don’t try and be your own lawyer if something goes wrong, but you can’t limit your liability if you have no idea what type of system your state uses.
I know the fence requirements in some states as outlined in the code have no bearing on the reality of what we actually use. Minimum of 4ft? Must be all wood? 6 foot for stallions and colts? Is that the reality these days when you look out your door? If you do not meet the state’s code requirements you might find yourself smack dab in the middle of strict liability. Or if the code asks for X and you do Y, that might be proof of your negligence. And guess what—many insurance policies do not cover your own negligence. They will try to avoid paying out the claim at the same time you are being sued by someone else or their insurance company. Nice.
I’ll dig up some You-tube examples for you to decide if you see negligence if you were on the jury or you were the judge.
Next we will talk some about other loose animals besides large livestock. Who is responsible for a dog bite?
Just like with liability in general, your liability and responsibilities will depend on your state. You have two sources of law: the state code and the case law that interprets what the state code means. For example, the state code may say "[a] person who owns or has responsibility for the control of a horse, mule, donkey, cow, bull, steer, hog, sheep, or goat may not knowingly permit the animal to traverse or roam at large, unattended, on the right-of-way of a highway. Now the courts must interpret “knowingly, highway, right of way and unattended. Each state will have a code and a big pile of case law to interpret that code. See “equinelaw.alisonrowe.com/2008/05/articles/livestock-laws/is-a-horseowner-liable-for-damages-if-a-horse-gets-loose” for an example of just how complicated this can be.
Some states have strict liability. That means if the animal is out and causes damages you pay. Nobody cares if you were at fault or negligent or knowingly did anything. You go straight from duty to damages with no stopping at breach or causation. Its out, you pay. Some states only hold you responsible for personal injuries if you negligently or knowingly let the animal get out. How they interpret “negligence” can range from “if its out you must have been negligent” (hence it becomes strict liability) to “you must have left a gate open or had ratty old fences or common practices that prove it’s your fault” or you win. Lastly, some states simply do not care. They put the burden on anyone out there to avoid loose livestock and fence it out or swerve around it if it’s on the road. You have no duty at all. They have a duty to not get hurt.
Why so much variation and interpretation about estrays? There are many reasons, but the biggest ones are that loose animals can cause serious damage and that often leads to insurance claims. Insurance companies can afford to fight legal battles as far as they can go. One loose horse can cause wrecked cars, dead people, permanent physical damage and extensive property damage. Someone has to pay and that is usually the insurance company. The other reason is simply the states historical traditions. Western states usually see livestock as having a right to everywhere they are not fenced out. Free range grazing is the norm so if you want a cow free yard or road you need to pay for the fence to keep them away. Eastern states are the opposite. You fence in or else. Depending on how often a code is updated adjoining counties may conflict so your farm may be half fence out and half fence in!
When you read case law you are usually reading the appeal of the original verdict. Most trial courts are not courts of record. You may read a short blurb or a news article about the case, but it is not until the appeal that legal opinions are rendered for publications by the courts. If its gotten as far as an appeal there is either a serious injury or an insurance company involved. A case like that would have taken several years and tens of thousands of dollars to reach an appellate decision. You do not see case law about Dobbin getting loose and eating neighbors Pansy patch. You see case law about horses on the road and smashed cars and broken bones or worse.
Often, the law is pretty clear on property damage from loose animals. You will pay for the Pansy patch or broken fence or ruined crops. When things get fuzzy and expensive is when some human or other animal gets injured. Vet bills and personal injury bills get expensive. The lawyers and insurance companies will try these cases and in some ways they make the judges make the laws. Whoever loses will almost certainly appeal. So you see lots of case law in this area.
So, how to find out the law in your state? First read the code. It’s usually under animals and or livestock. Then check your local county code. They may have something to say about animals too. Next, you will have to read the recent case law in your state. Sometimes it’s sort of surprising. For example, in Georgia they use a negligence standard, but the actual case law defines negligence in ways we might not. A horse got loose by breaking the gate and fence. The judge found that was negligence because the fence posts where not set in concrete. The horse had no history of breaking out or needing special fences, but the judge felt that if the posts had been set in concrete the horse would have not been able to escape. Kind of makes you wonder what a GA judge would think or electric wire fences?
You do not need to be a lawyer to look up case law and you do not need access to a law library or a subscription data base. Use google. Use the terms you are interested in like car+horse+injury but also use Plaintiff or Defendant or appellant and court. That will narrow down your results quite a bit. Don’t try and be your own lawyer if something goes wrong, but you can’t limit your liability if you have no idea what type of system your state uses.
I know the fence requirements in some states as outlined in the code have no bearing on the reality of what we actually use. Minimum of 4ft? Must be all wood? 6 foot for stallions and colts? Is that the reality these days when you look out your door? If you do not meet the state’s code requirements you might find yourself smack dab in the middle of strict liability. Or if the code asks for X and you do Y, that might be proof of your negligence. And guess what—many insurance policies do not cover your own negligence. They will try to avoid paying out the claim at the same time you are being sued by someone else or their insurance company. Nice.
I’ll dig up some You-tube examples for you to decide if you see negligence if you were on the jury or you were the judge.
Next we will talk some about other loose animals besides large livestock. Who is responsible for a dog bite?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)